Stadium Discussion

Where Do You Want The Stadium?

  • Manhattan

    Votes: 54 16.6%
  • Queens

    Votes: 99 30.5%
  • Brooklyn

    Votes: 19 5.8%
  • Staten Island

    Votes: 7 2.2%
  • Westchester

    Votes: 18 5.5%
  • The Bronx

    Votes: 113 34.8%
  • Long Island

    Votes: 7 2.2%
  • Dual-Boroughs

    Votes: 3 0.9%
  • Etihad Island

    Votes: 5 1.5%

  • Total voters
    325
Unless I'm mistaken, the USSF training center is used specifically for national team activities - it's not used as an individual academy that anybody can join, rather a location for each pool of age-group NT players to gather at when camps are conducted.

In the past, it was at a Chula Vista - using the USOC facilities - and then it was moved to Carson, Ca in a partnership with the (former Home Depot) StubHub Center (LA Galaxy) in 2003. This helped to cut down on overhead because facilities were shared and the USSF didn't need them every day of the year. Additionally, these locations were used because most of the US coaches were based in CA (Bora, Sampson, Klinnsman) and it was convenient to fly to Central America. Bucking the trend, when Arena first managed, he was with DCUnited and the MNT had a lot of camps on the east coast rather than go to a Chula Vista.

I guess one could argue that it provided an unfair advantage to the LA Galaxy, but really USSF was just another tenant paying rent and using the facilities. Any team could conceivably do that for the extra revenue. Personally, I think that if an MLS club wants to enter into a partnership with USSF, and in doing so have essentially a cathedral for training albeit one that is not 100% their own, then I have no problem with it. I would expect their stadium to also be used as a "national" stadium for many games. If not for the Field Turf at Mercedes-Benz in ATL, I could see Atlanta being the landing spot as that would be a ridiculously amazing venue for high profile matches, convenient to the West coast & Europe, a monster airport with routes everywhere, and perfect weather for training.

Sure, but the article quoted says that USSF are considering building a facility "like Clairefontaine", and the FFF definitely run Clairefontaine as an academy in and of itself. In fairness, the article also cites Coverciano, which I thought was another national academy but apparently is just the Italian training base, so perhaps I am wrong after all, but the mentioning of Clairefontaine gave me the impression that the USSF had bigger ideas.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Kjbert
giphy.gif
 
The club would be insane to move outside the boroughs. Subways or not, they would lose a considerable amount of support because the team's identity is centered around being a NYC team located in the boroughs.

Remove that, and NYCFC is nothing more than another RBNY with a different badge.
 
I am in Bronxville, which borders Mt. Vernon to the north. Let me look more closely. There are no subway stops in Mt. Vernon, but 3 Metro North stops. Mt. Vernon borders the Bronx, so depending on location, subway might work too.
 
Can anyone from westchester or mount vernon put some input into this? How far is this from subway stations?
Half hour walk to the 5 is the closest. I can't take the proposal seriously. Not because the team won't move to Mt. Vernon - the mayor of that city has a right to try and good for him on that account. But they have to know that 15k is absolutely inadequate. I say the mayor wants to do this for completely unrelated reasons and NYCFC is a convenient talking point.
 
I am glad someone is starting to try an "lure" us, maybe it gets the competition rolling, but like spock said, fuck no. A stadium in mt. vernon and I am done.

But on a brighter note, my brother has a house in pelham on the mt. vernon border that's a 10 min bike ride / 25 min walk from there. And yet I still say fuck no.

I say the mayor wants to do this for completely unrelated reasons and NYCFC is a convenient talking point.

Yes, this. Thats why i put quotes on lure. He's just drumming up a conversation on this crumbling field. nothing more.
 
That part of Mt. Vernon isn't very close to the MTA stations or the subway stations. It's over by Pelham. It's an 18 minute walk from the Pelham Metro North stop and a 30 minute walk from the Eastchester/Dyre Ave subway stop.

It's nice to be wanted, but I don't see this as a real solution.

Also, I think this site was mentioned earlier. I remembered that when I read that this is where the Mean Joe Greene Coke commercial was filmed.
 
That part of Mt. Vernon isn't very close to the MTA stations or the subway stations. It's over by Pelham. It's an 18 minute walk from the Pelham Metro North stop and a 30 minute walk from the Eastchester/Dyre Ave subway stop.

It's nice to be wanted, but I don't see this as a real solution.

Also, I think this site was mentioned earlier. I remembered that when I read that this is where the Mean Joe Greene Coke commercial was filmed.

I was asking since that green info graphic in the article says 2 subways stop. I think that site woulf be great if soccer was more popular a second division team could end up there, and fight for promotion.
 
15k is a non-starter. The team probably has given some fleeting thoughts to MV and Yonkers (both discussed on here somewhere within the 438 pages) but Westchester really isn't and shouldn't be in consideration (notwithstanding my love for my old stomping grounds.)
 
  • Like
Reactions: Victors87
I was asking since that green info graphic in the article says 2 subways stop. I think that site woulf be great if soccer was more popular a second division team could end up there, and fight for promotion.

Fair enough. The Green Graphic is BS. There are places in Mt. Vernon that are close to subway lines, but that's not one of them.

Maybe a stadium for the Cosmos? Right size, for sure.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Victors87
There are worse places for a training ground or USL squad.

It's a relatively famous location here in Westchester.

I am OK moving to something that borders the Bronx. I've been a proponent of working with Yonkers to build it on the Yonkers/Bronx border.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Christopher Jee