At The Forum Party, The Nick-nack Paddy Whack Cheer Was Repeated.
- Thread starter Midas Mulligan
- Start date
as the evening progressed i tried to start vulgar to more vulgar chants to no avail ... my "you're playing like shit, you're playing like shit, your name is KAKA, you're playing like shit" chant got absolutely no love, neither did the "we're not extra fancy, NO we don't dive like Nancys, we don't give a fuck, cause we're NYC" (to the tune of we're not gonna take it) ... at least people joined the knock knack paddy wack one.
Surprisingly this wasn't done at Banter in Williamsburg at all. Vamos Mi Celeste seemed to be the default chant, which I liked.
It'll take time for chants to become absorbed by the majority. Right now the simpler a chant is the more likely people will pick up on it.
Give it time my friend.
Give it time my friend.
Reason number 59 why I question the fact I've sent them dues money. Twice.
Now who's the sucka in this story?
Did anyone chant the Mix song? Now that's one to make your ears bleed.
I dunno. It wasn't THAT bad ¯\_(ツ)_/¯ definitely catchy. Especially after you've downed a few haha
I don't mind the idea behind the chant, but whoever wrote it has no sense of rhythm. The third line is nothing like the the original song, and every time I've heard it sung it sounds like they drunkenly forgot what they were saying in the middle of the line and then tried to half-heartedly jam too much in at the end.
Here's my super-legit MS Paint musical analysis:
(and yes, there is an extra beat in that last measure)
Here's my super-legit MS Paint musical analysis:
(and yes, there is an extra beat in that last measure)
You guys are crazy if you think we're singing "You'll Never Walk Alone" on Day 1. It's a great chant for what we have. All it is, is shot after shot at the only people who are trying. There was a solid and diverse crowd at Ryans Daughter... Did you start a chant to get everyone going?
I did. Just "New York - City".
Someone not having come up with a "better" chant is not a reasonable rebuttal to chant being shit.
There is a video of this chant after the Mix goal... I'll hide it just case because once heard it cannot be unheard. So cringe-worthy.
Im biased but i submitted a chant for mix this morning that is not cring worthy http://nycfcforums.com/index.php?threads/mix-diskerud-goal.2430/
Nah, it's not that bad rhythmically (it's a pretty bland song all in all, though). You're missing that there is an anacrusis in the NYC chant that isn't there in the knick-knack song - the first two syllables come before the first bar. In other words, the music is actually like this:
(I know that I could have made that picture easier to view, but I'm too lazy to fix it, sorry).
Attachments
That's my exact problem! What does it even mean?
Similar threads
