NYCFC Mount Rushmore

Can I make an argument for Vieira? The club has been a disaster off the field since year one. I don’t even want to know what we look like if year 2 didn’t have such a turnaround.

then maybe you put Kreiss. Without his fucking shit up so badly, we might not get PV or any of the other changes that came with.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Schwallacus
Callens is #2 behind Taty. Might be #1.
Villa can contend for greatest player but the harassment stuff is a DQ for a monument.
Maxi and Johnson are great, but Callens has been the rock.

Callens is the greatest defender this club has ever had. He’s been here since 2017, has had ironman seasons where he’s played every game, and has matured into a full international player for Peru while leading the back line at NYCFC.

He also scored two decisive penalties (Revs and the final) that brought NYCFC its first cup.

I’m also in the camp that the harassment stuff dq’s Villa.

Taty, Maxi, Callens, Sean.
 
Callens is the greatest defender this club has ever had. He’s been here since 2017, has had ironman seasons where he’s played every game, and has matured into a full international player for Peru while leading the back line at NYCFC.

He also scored two decisive penalties (Revs and the final) that brought NYCFC its first cup.

I’m also in the camp that the harassment stuff dq’s Villa.

Taty, Maxi, Callens, Sean.
100% agree on Callens! Villa MUST be in the top four!
 
  • Like
Reactions: Marito
Villa, Maxi, Callens, Taty.

if one has issues with Villa, then Johnson.

Callens edges Johnson as he has at times been the best CB in the league. Sean is great, but not sure he has ever been the best.