NYCFC Survivor (Round 11) - 8 Left!

Most votes gets eliminated! (1 vote)

  • Héber Araújo dos Santos

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • Sean Johnson

    Votes: 2 10.0%
  • Anton Tinnerholm

    Votes: 2 10.0%
  • Alexander Callens

    Votes: 1 5.0%
  • James Sands

    Votes: 1 5.0%
  • Maximiliano Moralez

    Votes: 3 15.0%
  • Alexander Ring

    Votes: 1 5.0%
  • Ismael Tajouri-Shradi

    Votes: 10 50.0%

  • Total voters
    20
  • Poll closed .

Shwafta

MLS Cup Attendee
Elite Donor
Jan 16, 2018
7,406
10,397
303
26
Long Island
I don't have a rhyme for "Taty" or "Castellanos", sorry. Bye to Taty Castellanos

8 Left!


Vote for the player you want to get eliminated. This does not have to be your least favorite player, just who you want to get eliminated. (Troll, etc.)

In the case of a tie, all tied players will be eliminated.

1 votes for this round!
 
  • Like
Reactions: Schwallacus
Seriously? What’s with ITS getting all the votes? Dude scored the only NYCFC goal against Toronto. I’m voting for the guy who is terrible at penalties but won’t step aside. Know your lane MAXI.
 
Seriously? What’s with ITS getting all the votes? Dude scored the only NYCFC goal against Toronto. I’m voting for the guy who is terrible at penalties but won’t step aside. Know your lane MAXI.
He sure did :)
...But the others are better / bigger fan favorites. heh
 
  • Like
Reactions: SoupInNYC
Seriously? What’s with ITS getting all the votes? Dude scored the only NYCFC goal against Toronto. I’m voting for the guy who is terrible at penalties but won’t step aside. Know your lane MAXI.

Yeah, Isi is one of the best goal scorers in MLS in terms of goals vs. shots. But he's been injured, so that must be it.
 
Seriously? What’s with ITS getting all the votes? Dude scored the only NYCFC goal against Toronto. I’m voting for the guy who is terrible at penalties but won’t step aside. Know your lane MAXI.
As Shwafta Shwafta said, its due to the others still involved and I can't see myself voting for them at this moment. It's a tough decision.

But I am willing to listen to an argument that I should vote for someone else and change my vote :)
 
  • Like
Reactions: Shwafta
I also voted for Isi because he's hurt too much. That wasn't enough early in the game but we're getting down to the end here. I can see Heber going out for the same reason.
 
  • Like
Reactions: SoupInNYC
I also voted for Isi because he's hurt too much. That wasn't enough early in the game but we're getting down to the end here. I can see Heber going out for the same reason.
Hmm, I figure that unless people troll, the final 3 are gonna be Sands, Heber, Tinnerholm.

...but I guess we'll find out soon! haha
 
I also voted for Isi because he's hurt too much. That wasn't enough early in the game but we're getting down to the end here. I can see Heber going out for the same reason.

Heber for being injured. Maxi for missing PKs. Johnson for not communicating on the header in the playoffs vs. Toronto.

Nothing egregious comes to mind for Tinnerholm, Ring, or Sands.
 
  • Like
Reactions: mgarbowski
Heber for being injured. Maxi for missing PKs. Johnson for not communicating on the header in the playoffs vs. Toronto.

Nothing egregious comes to mind for Tinnerholm, Ring, or Sands.
I'm not sure how many people blame Johnson for that.

If we're looking for reasons to vote someone off:

Ring shoots too many wild shots.
Sands got hurt twice in a row and is going to leave soon anyway (so maybe kick him out first?).
Tinnerholm became TinnerBOOM on the basis of two screamers in his first 5 games and then . . . well, not so many. And his backups are not good. If he gets hurt we're screwed. Yes you can blame him for that if you want.
 
Last edited:
I'm not sure how many people blame Johnson for that.

If we're looking for reasons to vote someone off:

Ring shoots too many wild shots.
Sands got hurt twice in a row and is going to leave soon anyway (so maybe kick him out first?).
Tinnerholm became TinnerBOOM on the basis two screamers in his first 5 games and then . . . well, not so many. And his backups are not good. If he gets hurt we're screwed. Yes you can blame him for that if you want.

Johnson should have known that Pozeulo was going to do a panenka o_O
 
I'm not sure how many people blame Johnson for that.

If we're looking for reasons to vote someone off:

Ring shoots too many wild shots.
Sands got hurt twice in a row and is going to leave soon anyway (so maybe kick him out first?).
Tinnerholm became TinnerBOOM on the basis two screamers in his first 5 games and then . . . well, not so many. And his backups are not good. If he gets hurt we're screwed. Yes you can blame him for that if you want.
Was looking forward to finding out if Scally has the goods to fill in for Tinny this season.
Heber for being injured. Maxi for missing PKs. Johnson for not communicating on the header in the playoffs vs. Toronto.

Nothing egregious comes to mind for Tinnerholm, Ring, or Sands.

I have a criticism of Ring... it falls into the fine line category I suppose. His intensity and aggressive play is what we love about him. However, I often find myself feeling A foul he has committed is pointless and actually tactically stupid. In the “heat of battle” with the way he plays maybe that’s inevitable.
I feel he could still play his game while being more disciplined and smarter with his tackling.
 
SJ is a lovable guy, so it hurts to vote for him but he got my vote this round. Seems he has the potential to be a great keeper, even world class, but each time he gets close he ends up doing something stupid or letting in a soft goal. The own goal vs. Minnesota and other games where we should've won but a slip up by him or Chanot cost us. An example being that game vs. DC where we had 20 shots and DC had one, a header that could've been saved, that went in. Should've had 3 pts but ended up with 1.