NYCFC Survivor (Round 12) - 7 Left!

Most votes gets eliminated! (1 vote)

  • Maximiliano Moralez

    Votes: 2 10.0%
  • Héber Araújo dos Santos

    Votes: 1 5.0%
  • Sean Johnson

    Votes: 6 30.0%
  • Alexander Ring

    Votes: 1 5.0%
  • James Sands

    Votes: 2 10.0%
  • Anton Tinnerholm

    Votes: 2 10.0%
  • Alexander Callens

    Votes: 6 30.0%

  • Total voters
    20
  • Poll closed .

Shwafta

MLS Cup Attendee
Elite Donor
Jan 16, 2018
7,406
10,397
303
26
Long Island
Ismael Tajouri-Shradi has been eliminated!

7 Left!

Vote for the player you want to get eliminated. This does not have to be your least favorite player, just who you want to get eliminated. (Troll, etc.)

In the case of a tie, all tied players will be eliminated.

1 votes for this round!

Poll Closes June 6th at 2:15PM
 
Last edited:
1. Damn you people taking ITS out!
2. How dare you go for Sean. Dude is the only reason NYCFC can compete some games. You want him to score as well!
 
  • Haha
Reactions: Shwafta
dear world... open your hearts and minds and please recognize Sean for his stellar play between the posts and his passion on the pitch. Think to the times he’s kept NYCFC in the game while 10 of his teammates run around like slow motion keystone cops.
Thank you for listening.
 
  • Like
Reactions: SoupInNYC
dear world... open your hearts and minds and please recognize Sean for his stellar play between the posts and his passion on the pitch. Think to the times he’s kept NYCFC in the game while 10 of his teammates run around like slow motion keystone cops.
Thank you for listening.
SeanJohn is perhaps my favorite player on the team, he's likeable plus being in the NT pool makes it even easier to pull for him.

However, I did vote for him this round. Why? It comes down to the replacement potential. First, I think a goalkeeper at that salary could be found fairly easily compared to other positions imo. Second, a goalkeeper can generally be easier to integrate into the squad quickly. With field players, it takes a while, sometimes an entire season, to mix well into the lineup and reach potential, while some are simply not a good fit.

So I voted from a "who can most easily be replaced" perspective, and I think that is SJ.
 
  • Like
Reactions: SoupInNYC
SeanJohn is perhaps my favorite player on the team, he's likeable plus being in the NT pool makes it even easier to pull for him.

However, I did vote for him this round. Why? It comes down to the replacement potential. First, I think a goalkeeper at that salary could be found fairly easily compared to other positions imo. Second, a goalkeeper can generally be easier to integrate into the squad quickly. With field players, it takes a while, sometimes an entire season, to mix well into the lineup and reach potential, while some are simply not a good fit.

So I voted from a "who can most easily be replaced" perspective, and I think that is SJ.

See, this is what makes the competition interesting. Whether people are voting based on personality? potential? current ability? none/all? So it's interesting to see what everyone thinks.
 
See, this is what makes the competition interesting. Whether people are voting based on personality? potential? current ability? none/all? So it's interesting to see what everyone thinks.
To be honest, I had shifted my voting criteria several times. Early on, it was easy. Who is unlikely to get serious minutes? Then it was who is clearly a backup? Once we got down to XI, it's very hard, especially when we saw team performance drop last season when any one player was injured.
The replacement factor is my latest method. It's going to get harder and harder.
 
To be honest, I had shifted my voting criteria several times. Early on, it was easy. Who is unlikely to get serious minutes? Then it was who is clearly a backup? Once we got down to XI, it's very hard, especially when we saw team performance drop last season when any one player was injured.
The replacement factor is my latest method. It's going to get harder and harder.
After this round, there will be six left, which means the option to just roll a die becomes available.
 
I was going to vote for maxi but changed to callens in the protect SJ camp. Can we just eliminate all but ring sands and tindy. That’s where it will get fun.