Yellow Card Accumulation (updated Oct 7)

[Seth]

Man, that would be a disaster if Villa went out on yellow card accumulation because he took his shirt off! What post-Victorian reason is that a reason for giving a yellow card? Is this an MLS rule or one adopted from FIFA?

I can't imagine Brandi Chastain got a yellow card for her celebration!

"Removing one's shirt after scoring is unnecessary and players should avoid such excessive displays of joy."

Source: http://www.fifa.com/development/new...law-yellow-card-for-removal-jersey-92958.html


Actual page from FIFA rules:

I swear, that arrow is in the rule book and I did not add it in!

Source (PDF download): http://www.fifa.com/mm/document/afdeveloping/refereeing/law_12_fouls_misconduct_en_47379.pdf

That's page 50. Worth downloading for the other jersey photos on page 51-54. Bonus on page 55: masks!

 

[Seven]

Man, that would be a disaster if Villa went out on yellow card accumulation because he took his shirt off! What post-Victorian reason is that a reason for giving a yellow card? Is this an MLS rule or one adopted from FIFA?

I can't imagine Brandi Chastain got a yellow card for her celebration!

The rule went into effect in July of 2004

 

[NYC24]

I don't know how to quote text from my mobile but maybe you (you know who you are) should try not to be such a donkey and people might talk to you IRL not just an online forum.

I stand by both prior statements. Villa showed emotion and leadership to get #3. #4 was unlucky.

 

[NYC24]

I don't know how to quote text from my mobile but maybe you (you know who you are) should try not to be such a donkey and you people might talk to you IRL not just an online forum.

I stand by both prior statements. Villa showed emotion and leadership to get #3. #4 was unlucky.

 

[mgarbowski]

I don't know how to quote text from my mobile but maybe you (you know who you are) should try not to be such a donkey and people might talk to you IRL not just an online forum.

I stand by both prior statements. Villa showed emotion and leadership to get #3. #4 was unlucky.

Oh, burn me. You have exposed the sadness that is my life, with a beautiful family, productive hobby, and excellent career.
And this after I very nicely said in another thread that I hope you enjoy the new tickets you're adding. Cheers, and good-bye.

 

[NYC24]

For what it is worth your comment (I think it was you) about there only being 4 games in Sept and 3 in Oct is a very good point. The podcast hosts should have mentioned that and taken into account in their analysis

 

[LionNYC]

If Villa gets two yellows in one game (before he gets the fair play benefit) would he miss two games?

 

[danger]

No yellow card:
- tingling nipples

 

[Gotham Gator]

Villa has shown more heart and fight that anyone in this team so far. For sure he'll get another yellow and someone else will need to step up.

I worry about this too. His effort and determination involves taking risks, and that means there is a good chance he will pick up another yellow in the next 3 games like the one he picked up yesterday. It may not even be likely, but it's far from zero and is something everyone will watch closely.

 

[danger]

There were long spells between his first (CHI 5/15) and second (NJ 6/28), and the second and third (DC 8/13). It's just the third and fourth back to back and that's only because he took his shirt off

 

[Seth]

View attachment 3252
No yellow card:
- tingling nipples

Yeah, I sent that one in to Men in Blazers via Twitter. They haven't replied back with an invitation to be on the show yet, alas, but it's only been a couple of days.

And hey, doesn't that look like a young Dana Carvey?

 

[Gotham Gator]

Updated for LA and added a note about the next game.

 

[Gotham Gator]

Updated for Dallas.

 

[Gene]

Villa should be in the clear now.

 

[Gotham Gator]

Updated for Toronto game. Hernandez is now one yellow away from his second suspension.

Edited to fix count on Saunders, who now has 4.

 

[Gotham Gator]

Updated for San Jose.

We lose Wingert for Vancouver.

Jacobson, Allen, Saunders and Watson-Siraboe are all sitting on 4 yellows.

 

[Fantazma]

Updated for San Jose.

We lose Wingert for Vancouver.

Jacobson, Allen, Saunders and Watson-Siraboe are all sitting on 4 yellows.

lol

jacobson/ saunders the only huge losses if a yellow is obtained.

 

[Gotham Gator]

lol

jacobson/ saunders the only huge losses if a yellow is obtained.

Agree - assuming that Iraola is ready to go as Kreis implied post match.

 

[Gotham Gator]

Updated for Vancouver.

 

[benitolorenzi]

I think this could be a straight red.