Pigeons at Crew... U Pick!

[Gotham Gator]

Pick the score, the goalscorers and their order, and the MVP (Most Valuable Pigeon). The player picking the correct result (win, lose, draw) and coming closest to the actual score wins a Mug of Ale from me should we ever meet and his/her name permanently enshrined in the Hall of Victory!

NOTE: This pick is for the first leg only.

Good Luck!

New Tiebreaker Rules
Tiebreakers, in order:
(1) correct result (win, lose, draw)*
(2) closest to the actual score
(3) correctly naming the most goalscorers
(4) correct goalscoring order (by team)
* - a player cannot win by picking a win if the result is a loss (and vice versa)

GIF of the Game!

Hall of Victory
View attachment 7600 - JCMore

- dannd23

- joe

- JGarrettLieb & The Toe

- The Toe

- Gotham Gator
View attachment 7600 - ferrarinycfc

- Shawn S

- Shawn S

- Shawn S

- no winner
View attachment 7600 - JJJSMAC

- Gotham Gator

- Gotham Gator

- ferrarinycfc & JJJSMAC
View attachment 7599 - Gotham Gator

- The Toe
View attachment 7599 - Gotham Gator

- JGarrettLieb & Seven

- ferrarinycfc

- canchon

- Seven

- Gotham Gator
View attachment 7599 - JGarrettLieb & Seven

- Joseph Bianco

- Joseph Bianco
View attachment 7599 - The Toe

- joe

- Etnaman

- Mario

- Etnaman

- Kangaroo Jack

- ferrarinycfc

- JGarrettLieb

- Jon

 

[Mario]

NYC 2- 1 Crew

Villa, kamara, maxi
MVP Villa

 

[ferrarinycfc]

0-0

 

[The Toe]

2-3 Crew

Kamara
Harrison
Kamara
Meram
Villa

MOTM: Maxi

 

[Ulrich]

Villa’s Firm 5-1 Steffen’s Mortal

Chanot (he starts and is back)
Harrison
Villa
Higuin
Villa
Ring

Steffen comes back to reality and can’t stop every shot like Superman. NYCFC’s 13 shots on goal finally break through.

 

[adam]

Villa’s Firm 5-1 Steffen’s Mortal

Chanot (he starts and is back)
Harrison
Villa
Higuin
Villa
Ring

Steffen comes back to reality and can’t stop every shot like Superman. NYCFC’s 13 shots on goal finally break through.

Then who do we start/rest in the 2nd leg...

 

[Ulrich]

Then who do we start/rest in the 2nd leg...

Definitely rest TMac, Khiry, and Pirlo, anlthough we’d be nearly safe to allow Pirlo a 10min cameo appearance at the very end.

 

[LionNYC]

Then who do we start/rest in the 2nd leg...

Columbus would have to win 5-0 at Yankee Stadium. And that's only been done twice, RB Wedding and Toronto 2nd Leg. Both in 2016.

Anyone on a yellow card. Anyone with a slight knock.

Because the next match is November 21st. Stupid FIFA International Break ruining the playoffs.

 

[LionNYC]

NYCFC 3 - CCSC 1

Wallace
Wallace
Kamara
Villa

 

[Sabo]

Ring
Kamara
Villa

Going home with the lead and 2 away goals.

 

[canchon]

1-1

Higuain
Villa

MVP: Ring - but since he’ll never get acknowledged for it - Villa

 

[adam]

3-0

Tummy 22'
RJ 41'
Khiry 74'

MVP: Pirlo with 3 assists

It will be magical!

Edit: his assists will be absolutely brilliant coming from New York

 

[joe]

3-2

Villa, Maxi, Brillant

 

[Seven]

2-2

Villa
Kamara
Manneh
Villa

MVillaP

 

[Gotham Gator]

NYC 2
CLB 2

Villa
Kamara
Higuain
Harrison

MVP: Harrison

 

[dannd23]

New York City Football Club 4 Columbus 2
Higuain (3')
Kamara (5')
everyone panics....
Villa (6')
Villa (12')
Ring (34')
Villa (56')

MVP: Villa

 

[Gotham Gator]

2-3 Crew

Kamara
Harrison
Kamara
Meram
Villa

MOTM: Maxi

Winner