Problems To Fix: Let's Take A Look To Our Roster. Part 1.

NYJaguar

Registered
Seasoned Supporter
Goalkeepers: Here is clear that Josh Saunders has exceed our expectations. He's has hearth, he has saved us many times. We would be worst without him. He's has earned his place as starting GK. Then we have Ryan Meara. I'm not going to destroy a guy for that awful mistake against Chicago, but that is bound to happen when you don't play regularly. He is not going to be better than Saunders until he gets more playtime and more experience (and I don't see that happening anytime soon). Then we have Akira Fitzgerald and Eirik Johansen: they are "young" and lack experience, both should only see the pitch in case of emergency. We currently have one GK too many. That roster spot could be used somewhere else. Either loan one of them out or trade him.

Right Backs: One of our worst problems. Josh Williams is not that effective attacking (like every other RB) and I feel that he has a hard time getting back. One of the goals at Philadelphia and yesterday's second goal are just exploits of all the space that he leave's behind. If you are a right back and you are going to attack, make sure that someone (CDM) is covering for you and be ready to react to counters. The same could be say about Brovsky (for me, a little bit more effective going forward). Then we have Shay Facey, with a lot of potential and physical the more apt of our RBs, but with all lack of experience of someone who hasn't play professionally. Shay should be a back up, not a solution. Same for, R.J. Allen (it has been unfair with him: playing two really fast wide outs for both games; he's not on the best shape). I would love to have someone better here.

Center Backs: I have been reasonably happy with Jason Hernandez and Chris Wingert, but they have to improve. Kwame Watson-Siriboe doesn't have enough to be a started or even our fist option coming from the bench. This brings me to one of our biggest problems: What is going on with Andres Mendoza? The Front Office preached about his talent and about him being a product of the great scouting network that we have. So? The only thing that they are saying is that he's adapting to a new life, but this guy is a professional soccer player, not a lonely teenager arriving by himself to the big city. If he is not better than Kwame, what's the point of keeping him around?

Left backs: I was so happy when Javier Calle finally started clicking as a LB, and I believe that he's our guy moving forward (or if we get a better CB than Wingert, move Wingert to the left). Brovsky seems more comfortable playing as RB. RJ Allen should not be our first option. We also have Connor Brandt, but he doesn't seem to be on Kreis plans (nor he should be other than as a development player). Let's loan him out to Wilmington and free up some roster space.
 
Last edited:
I get a lot what your saying however I'll point out that loaning a player (outside of a season long loan) to any place will still leave that player on NYCFC's roster and count against the MLS cap (unless they are player #22-28).

Do we really think that NYCFC wil go get many replacements in the summer transfer window? I don't.
 
seems to me like this is going to be a 2 year building process, i cant see them turnoving the roster in only one year. The way i see it, the current roster has some players worth keeping long term but they are mostly young players that cant be relied upon. I would hang on to the followng and replace everyone else over the next two off seasons. Seems like the second half of the roster is in ok shape , just need starters haha.

Saunders
Villa
Mix
Calle
Mendoza
Mullins
Mcnamara
Dunn
Shelton
Poku
Taylor
Facey
Brandt

Also, in my mind the players that cant get out of town faster enough are grabavoy, jacobsen, nemec, brovsky and williams
 
Really, you want to keep Dunn but kick Grabavoy, Jacobson and Nemec out the door? When has Nemec even played last?
 
Really, you want to keep Dunn but kick Grabavoy, Jacobson and Nemec out the door? When has Nemec even played last?
yeah , I would keep Dunn only because of his age and cost, need players in that salary range to round out the roster and he is young enough that he still has potential. yes, others need to go. I have seen all I need to see from nemec, not an MLS quality player and that is saying a lot. The players I would keep are mostly young and cheap. I think, In order to be a real contender which I wouldnt expect for 2 seasons just about the entire starting XI needs to be turned over with the exception of villa, diskerud, calle and saunders.
 
I get a lot what your saying however I'll point out that loaning a player (outside of a season long loan) to any place will still leave that player on NYCFC's roster and count against the MLS cap (unless they are player #22-28).

Do we really think that NYCFC wil go get many replacements in the summer transfer window? I don't.

Ok, thanks for pointing this out. But it still will make more sense sending Johansen and Brandt away and recall them just in case of emergency. They are last on the depth chart, let them develop somewhere else.

Also, I accidentally posted on the wrong forum. Sorry.
 
Ok, thanks for pointing this out. But it still will make more sense sending Johansen and Brandt away and recall them just in case of emergency. They are last on the depth chart, let them develop somewhere else.

Also, I accidentally posted on the wrong forum. Sorry.


What forum did you want this posted in? I think this one works.
 
What forum did you want this posted in? I think this one works.

They moved it already (it was at Team News).

What -realistic- players would you bring to improve our defense? I like Kofi Sarkodie or Sheanon Williams. Both of them had similar wages to Josh Williams last year (Sarkodie it's a little more expensive).
 
They moved it already (it was at Team News).

What -realistic- players would you bring to improve our defense? I like Kofi Sarkodie or Sheanon Williams. Both of them had similar wages to Josh Williams last year (Sarkodie it's a little more expensive).
Both are decent players but NYCFC doesn't really have anything in trade. Both Houston and Philly are struggling and both players are starters. I don't think they would even want Williams+Allocation Money for either player, hence NYCFC's conundrum.
 
1. We need to get and keep our players fit: John, Villa, Brandt, McNamara, Meara.
2. We need to move to a 4-3-3 and play with more pace and width.
3. We need to use our most effective players: Calle, Poku, Mendoza (maybe?)
4. We need to drop our 'experienced MLSers' that aren't performing: Grabavoy, Brovsky, Wingert.
5. We need 4/5 more quality players.

We need a quick, intelligent striker to feed off Villa (Shelton's quick, but not intelligent). We need a quality defensive midfielder who can break up play and spray a decent pass (potentially use a DP slot here). We need a goal threat from midfield (other than Ballouchy), Lampard fits the bill. We need attacking fullbacks and a proper MLS quality centre-back (or preferably 2). Ideally:

In:
Kelechi Iheanacho - Man City - Loan
Frank Lampard - Man City - DP
Nigel de Jong - AC Milan - DP
Matt Hedges - FC Dallas - Trade
Angelino - Man City - Loan

Out:
Facey
Fitzgerald
Dunn
Kwame
Ballouchy
Taylor - Injury replacement

GK: Saunders, Meara, Johansen
RB: Williams, Brovsky
LB: Angelino, Allen, Brandt
CB: John, Hedges, Hernandez, Mendoza, Wingert
DM: de Jong, Jacobson
CM: Lampard, Mix, Poku, Grabavoy, McNamara
RW: Calle, Shelton, Alvarez
LW: Villa, Velasquez
ST: Kelechi, Mullins, Nemec

---------------------------------------Saunders
---------Williams----------John---------------Hedges--------Angelino/Calle
----------------------------------------de Jong
----------------------------Mix-----------------------Lampard
------------Calle/Shelton---------------------------------------------Villa
---------------------------------------Iheanacho

Angelino, Calle, Shelton and Alvarez rotate. Poku to come in for Lampard when injured/rested. Mendoza/Hernandez to play until John is fully fit.
 
Why would Dallas trade their captain to us? And Man City will only loan us scrubs that have no real potential.
 
1. We need to get and keep our players fit: John, Villa, Brandt, McNamara, Meara.
2. We need to move to a 4-3-3 and play with more pace and width.
3. We need to use our most effective players: Calle, Poku, Mendoza (maybe?)
4. We need to drop our 'experienced MLSers' that aren't performing: Grabavoy, Brovsky, Wingert.
5. We need 4/5 more quality players.

We need a quick, intelligent striker to feed off Villa (Shelton's quick, but not intelligent). We need a quality defensive midfielder who can break up play and spray a decent pass (potentially use a DP slot here). We need a goal threat from midfield (other than Ballouchy), Lampard fits the bill. We need attacking fullbacks and a proper MLS quality centre-back (or preferably 2). Ideally:

In:
Kelechi Iheanacho - Man City - Loan
Frank Lampard - Man City - DP
Nigel de Jong - AC Milan - DP
Matt Hedges - FC Dallas - Trade
Angelino - Man City - Loan

Out:
Facey
Fitzgerald
Dunn
Kwame
Ballouchy
Taylor - Injury replacement

GK: Saunders, Meara, Johansen
RB: Williams, Brovsky
LB: Angelino, Allen, Brandt
CB: John, Hedges, Hernandez, Mendoza, Wingert
DM: de Jong, Jacobson
CM: Lampard, Mix, Poku, Grabavoy, McNamara
RW: Calle, Shelton, Alvarez
LW: Villa, Velasquez
ST: Kelechi, Mullins, Nemec

---------------------------------------Saunders
---------Williams----------John---------------Hedges--------Angelino/Calle
----------------------------------------de Jong
----------------------------Mix-----------------------Lampard
------------Calle/Shelton---------------------------------------------Villa
---------------------------------------Iheanacho

Angelino, Calle, Shelton and Alvarez rotate. Poku to come in for Lampard when injured/rested. Mendoza/Hernandez to play until John is fully fit.

Very much agree with you highlighting that we need an upgrade at defensive midfield. For all the complaining about Jacobson, we don't have a viable alternative there right now. Haven't seen de Jong a lot since he went to Italy, but that type of player would be great.
 
Very much agree with you highlighting that we need an upgrade at defensive midfield. For all the complaining about Jacobson, we don't have a viable alternative there right now. Haven't seen de Jong a lot since he went to Italy, but that type of player would be great.
He's out of contract in the summer, I think we should look at him. Jeremy Toulalan (Monaco), Thiago Motta (PSG), Mathieu Flamini (Arsenal), Felipe Melo (Galatasaray) and Sandro (QPR) could all also be available.
 
He's out of contract in the summer, I think we should look at him. Jeremy Toulalan (Monaco), Thiago Motta (PSG), Mathieu Flamini (Arsenal), Felipe Melo (Galatasaray) and Sandro (QPR) could all also be available.
That's an interesting list. Thiago Motta is, for me, far and away the most interesting if he actually has interest in coming. As a Spurts supporter, I've long loved Sandro, but fear his knees are shot.
 
1. We need to get and keep our players fit: John, Villa, Brandt, McNamara, Meara.
2. We need to move to a 4-3-3 and play with more pace and width.
3. We need to use our most effective players: Calle, Poku, Mendoza (maybe?)
4. We need to drop our 'experienced MLSers' that aren't performing: Grabavoy, Brovsky, Wingert.
5. We need 4/5 more quality players.

We need a quick, intelligent striker to feed off Villa (Shelton's quick, but not intelligent). We need a quality defensive midfielder who can break up play and spray a decent pass (potentially use a DP slot here). We need a goal threat from midfield (other than Ballouchy), Lampard fits the bill. We need attacking fullbacks and a proper MLS quality centre-back (or preferably 2). Ideally:

In:
Kelechi Iheanacho - Man City - Loan
Frank Lampard - Man City - DP
Nigel de Jong - AC Milan - DP
Matt Hedges - FC Dallas - Trade
Angelino - Man City - Loan

Out:
Facey
Fitzgerald
Dunn
Kwame
Ballouchy
Taylor - Injury replacement

GK: Saunders, Meara, Johansen
RB: Williams, Brovsky
LB: Angelino, Allen, Brandt
CB: John, Hedges, Hernandez, Mendoza, Wingert
DM: de Jong, Jacobson
CM: Lampard, Mix, Poku, Grabavoy, McNamara
RW: Calle, Shelton, Alvarez
LW: Villa, Velasquez
ST: Kelechi, Mullins, Nemec

---------------------------------------Saunders
---------Williams----------John---------------Hedges--------Angelino/Calle
----------------------------------------de Jong
----------------------------Mix-----------------------Lampard
------------Calle/Shelton---------------------------------------------Villa
---------------------------------------Iheanacho

Angelino, Calle, Shelton and Alvarez rotate. Poku to come in for Lampard when injured/rested. Mendoza/Hernandez to play until John is fully fit.


1-4 Could be done today/already have been in place. Mostly rests on Kreis.
 
Why would Dallas trade their captain to us? And Man City will only loan us scrubs that have no real potential.
We tap him up? we offer several players? allocation money? I don't know, just think he would be a perfect fit.
I'm not sure about City not sending players with potential, Facey was pretty highly rated. If MCFC can loan players to more competitive leagues then they probably will.
 
Back
Top