2017 Forum H2H League & Pigeon Cup

If we did 3 divisions: High priced, Entry Priced and Free. What would you like to pay?

  • $100 - high priced

  • $75 - high priced

  • $50 - high priced

  • $25 - entry priced

  • $20 - entry priced

  • Free - lower division


Results are only viewable after voting.
So, looks like Week 1 does count for H2H. The standings are updated, and I'm the best team to lose this week. Yay.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Jack
So, looks like Week 1 does count for H2H. The standings are updated, and I'm the best team to lose this week. Yay.
That's ridiculous, before even looking at whether I won or lost. I checked out after I learned that it wasn't going to count and left my lineup in whatever state it was in.

ETA: I won and had the second highest score, and still think that it is unfair.
 
So, looks like Week 1 does count for H2H. The standings are updated, and I'm the best team to lose this week. Yay.

Wow are you going to hate this announcement. Seems I can't open up the league for Alex Da Silva Alex Da Silva. They locked it once the season started. I didnt expect week 1 to count. So I figured no big deal starting a new league and we all sign up there for week 2. Now we have to vote if we do that for an even 16 and $75 more in the pot, or leave it as is with the Average and not let Alex in.

Thoughts?
 
  • Like
Reactions: Midas Mulligan
That's ridiculous, before even looking at whether I won or lost. I checked out after I learned that it wasn't going to count and left my lineup in whatever state it was in.

Maybe you'll like the last announcement then.
 
They very clearly said it doesn't count. I believe they used the word "reset." If so, maybe they want to show the results to complete the test but it resets later in the week.

I couldn't find where they said it would reset, but I didn't look too hard.

Also, if they're locking the H2H leagues, it seems like they are intending for Week 1 to count.
 
Wow are you going to hate this announcement. Seems I can't open up the league for Alex Da Silva Alex Da Silva. They locked it once the season started. I didnt expect week 1 to count. So I figured no big deal starting a new league and we all sign up there for week 2. Now we have to vote if we do that for an even 16 and $75 more in the pot, or leave it as is with the Average and not let Alex in.

Thoughts?

I think if the agreement was to play H2H beginning in Week 2, we should make the effort to enforce the intentions.

That said, I could see one or two people not signing up in time for the Week 2 league and causing even more problems. Messy.
 
  • Like
Reactions: adam
I think if the agreement was to play H2H beginning in Week 2, we should make the effort to enforce the intentions.

That said, I could see one or two people not signing up in time for the Week 2 league and causing even more problems. Messy.

I won't kill our original league. But will privately message all of us a 2nd one to sign up for. If we can't all get into the new league by Friday, we go with our backup, minus Alex and hope the week 1 results are wiped as promised.
 
Reset was not the word:
"After the Opening Weekend Challenge, all scores will zero out from the first weekend – even in head-to-head leagues. That means everyone will start fresh in Round 2 as the chase for the grand prizes begins in earnest. Think of it as a round to hone your skills and get familiar with the new rules – with a sweet prize on the line!"
http://www.mlssoccer.com/post/2017/...ze-available-week-1-opening-weekend-challenge

Now maybe they meant that the point scores zero out even for players in H2H leagues, but the H2H results stand. That's arguably consistent with what they said but stupid on the merits and very poorly written. But I still think the H2H match results will zero out. Traditionally player $$ value changes at 9am Eastern the day after the last game of each round. They haven't changed yet and I think they will remain flat because the entire first round is of no effect
 
  • Like
Reactions: adam
So do I complain about losing to Josh by two points or not?
 
So a guy in our non-H2H forum group ranked in the top 100 globally (Lewis Lovers Jack Speiser). Far be it for me to critique the guy as he blew me out of the water, but why have jonathan lewis on your bench at $5.5 knowing he absolutely will not play this week and you have unlimited subs. If your going to put a dead space guy on your roster get the cheapest you can get and spend the money else ware. Too dedicated to a team theme that guy.
 
So a guy in our non-H2H forum group ranked in the top 100 globally (Lewis Lovers Jack Speiser). Far be it for me to critique the guy as he blew me out of the water, but why have jonathan lewis on your bench at $5.5 knowing he absolutely will not play this week and you have unlimited subs. If your going to put a dead space guy on your roster get the cheapest you can get and spend the money else ware. Too dedicated to a team theme that guy.

That's not even the most obviously point. He has McNamara ($7.5) and Rowe ($5.5) on his bench. Why spend $1.5 more on a goalkeeper you're not even going to use and $3.5 on a midfielder you're not going to use?
 
So, are we adding an additional player to get 16 teams?

Can we find two more people to bring it to 18?
 
Yeah leave me out, i don't want to cause a stir and fuck everything up. Thanks for the consideration though
 
Yeah leave me out, i don't want to cause a stir and fuck everything up. Thanks for the consideration though
You're fine if you already paid. Don't see a reason we can't get this rolling in the next 2 days. If the other two don't re-signup by end of day I'll email them a reminder.
 
  • Like
Reactions: adam
I am of course in again, just haven't signed up yet but will.