City vs. Galaxy... U Pick!

[Gotham Gator]

Pick the score, the goalscorers and their order, and the MVB (Most Valuable Blue). Closest to the actual score wins a Mug of Ale from me should we ever meet and their name permanently enshrined in the Hall of Victory! Tiebreaker is correctly naming the most goalscorers followed by correct order (by team).

Good Luck!

Hall of Victory

- LionNYC and mgarbowski

- Gotham Gator

- no winner

- Lasker

- JCMore

- JCMore

- roxfontaine

- Paul

- LionNYC

- Paul

- leilanikali420

- The Toe

- no winner

- Gene

- LionNYC

- adam

- mgarbowski, yogicen, leilanikali420

- Gene

- adam

- Paul

- Gotham Gator

- mgarbowski

- no winner

- Seth

- Goodfella, Paul, and S sbrylski

- S sbrylski

 

[Gotham Gator]

Note - This week, I am dropping the earlier requirement that a contestant has to pick the correct result in order to win. That is - it used to be that if the game was a draw, contestants had to pick a draw to win, or if NYCFC won, contestants had to pick an NYCFC victory to win. Now, the closest score will win, period.

 

[Goodfella]

NYC - 3
LAG - 2

Villa
Dos Santos
Keane
Lampard
Villa

MOTM - Villa

 

[Gene]

NYCFC: 2

Galaxy: 2

dos Santos
Villa
Zardes
Pirlo

MVP: Pirlo

 

[JCMore]

LA 4-3 NYC

Lamps
Gio
Robbie
Villa
Harrison
Gerard
Zardes

Mvp Pirlo

 

[JCMore]

Quick question about the rules. Say I pick a 1-1 tie and someone else picks a 4-3 NYC win. The actual score is 3-3 and that person picks 6 of the 7 goal scorers in order. Do I still win for picking the correct result if I were the only one to guess a tie? Or would they win for being the closest to the actual result?

 

[mgarbowski]

Quick question about the rules. Say I pick a 1-1 tie and someone else picks a 4-3 NYC win. The actual score is 3-3 and that person picks 6 of the 7 goal scorers in order. Do I still win for picking the correct result if I were the only one to guess a tie? Or would they win for being the closest to the actual result?

This is gonna get complicated.

 

[Hobo]

NYCFC - 4
LAG - 2

Villa x2
Dos Santos
Keane
Lamps x 2


MVP - Lamps

 

[Ulrich]

Quick question about the rules. Say I pick a 1-1 tie and someone else picks a 4-3 NYC win. The actual score is 3-3 and that person picks 6 of the 7 goal scorers in order. Do I still win for picking the correct result if I were the only one to guess a tie? Or would they win for being the closest to the actual result?

See last week's game and my question....

 

[Gotham Gator]

Quick question about the rules. Say I pick a 1-1 tie and someone else picks a 4-3 NYC win. The actual score is 3-3 and that person picks 6 of the 7 goal scorers in order. Do I still win for picking the correct result if I were the only one to guess a tie? Or would they win for being the closest to the actual result?

See last week's game and my question....

See second post in the thread. I have changed the (unwritten) rule that a person has to have the correct result to be eligible. Now, closest to the actual score wins.

 

[Gotham Gator]

NYC 1
LAG 1

Zardes
Lampard

MVB: Mena

 

[LionNYC]

NYCFC 3 - 1 LA

Harrison
Dos Santos
Villa
Lampard

MVP: Christian Lattanzio...Staying Perfect as a Coach

 

[leilanikali420]

NYC: 3
LA: 2

Keane
Villa
Harrison
Dos Santos
Lamps

MVP: Lamps

 

[Paul]

NYC: 3
LAG: 3

Keane
Villa
Lampard
Villa
Zardes
Lletget

 

[mgarbowski]

The Detective Sipowiczes 4
The Jason Nesmiths 3

Tommy "Medavoy" McNamara
Frank "Det. Kelly" Lampard
Robbie "Dr. Lazarus" Keane
Gyasi "Guy Fleegman" Zardes
Andreas "Det. Simone" Pirlo
David "Lt. Fancy" Villa
Giovanni "Mathesar" dos Santos

MOTM Bobby Simone (Pirlo)

 

[sbrylski]

Zardes 12'
Villa 23'
Villa 27'
Keane 44'
Keane 55'
McNamara 75'
Lampard 85'
Harrison 91'
Harrison 94'

Galaxy: 3
NYCFC: 6

 

[LionNYC]

NYC 1
LAG 1

Zardes
Lampard

MVB: Mena

Does this win? Closest score in terms of goals and GD but the incorrect result.

 

[Gotham Gator]

Does this win? Closest score in terms of goals and GD but the incorrect result.

Yes, it does.

Would you look at that! I change the rules and then I win!

 

[mgarbowski]

Yes, it does.

Would you look at that! I change the rules and then I win!

Stinks more than day-old murdered pigeon, I says.

 

[Gotham Gator]

Stinks more than day-old murdered pigeon, I says.

No, it tastes a good as an ice cold Mug of Ale.