Nick Cushing Named Interim HC (Jul '22) / HC (Nov '22) / Fired (Nov ‘24)

What Are Your Thoughts on Cushing as NYCFC Head Coach?

  • Quite Really Pleased

    Votes: 2 6.3%
  • Really Pleased

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • Pleased

    Votes: 2 6.3%
  • Neither Pleased or Displeased

    Votes: 5 15.6%
  • Displeased

    Votes: 7 21.9%
  • Really Displeased

    Votes: 3 9.4%
  • Quite Really Displeased

    Votes: 13 40.6%

  • Total voters
    32
So...contract ends in June/July 2025...

6 months sabbatical...

Starts as an MLS coach in January 2026...

1 year playing in YS/CF/RBA...

1-2 years playing in Etihad Point (I think our stadium will be called that)
Pep manning the sidelines at YS or CF would just be hilarious. Which is why I don’t think he comes here even with the CFG and NYC connection. It will be Miami or LA.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Kjbert
As long as he has it in his contract that he gets to moonlight refereeing U-12 games on Long Island, I am all in favor of it.
For anyone who didn't get the reference.

“Around 2013, a kids’ indoor soccer tournament in Rockville Centre, New York, found itself a referee short,” writes Kuper.

“One of the organisers asked the parents: Does anyone know the rules well enough to call a game? A Hispanic-looking man in a baseball cap volunteered.

“But he turned out to interpret his role rather broadly. He kept stopping the game to advise both teams on positioning. The watching parents, who had come to see their kids win, grew antsy. ‘Come on! Let them play!’ they shouted.

“The guy in the baseball cap, on sabbatical in New York after four draining seasons at Barça, was Pep Guardiola.”


 
Pep has a different relationship with CFG, and by all accounts, Pep loves NYC. Not saying it will happen, just that Dome and Pep are different cases.
And the guy who tried running Dome out (and ultimately kind of did) is no longer around
 
I think Cushing’s race is run. Probably not entirely his fault, how this season has gone, but at this point he’s gotten a bunch of new players and a little time to work with them, and it’s just not happening. I don’t see any patterns, don’t see any consistency of approach, and don’t see any team spirit.

It’s time.
 
Remember that the voting at the top of this thread can be changed by users at any time...
 
I'm really not going to like the idea of Cushing being scapegoated for this season when it was completely not his fault, but if there are not improvements by the end of the year then I agree that his time will be up. Frankly, our front office has shown that missing the playoffs is reason for a coach to be fired. But I don't like the idea that he will be scapegoated. This season is firmly on David Lee and the front office.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Joe_Cos and Gene
I'm really not going to like the idea of Cushing being scapegoated for this season when it was completely not his fault, but if there are not improvements by the end of the year then I agree that his time will be up. Frankly, our front office has shown that missing the playoffs is reason for a coach to be fired. But I don't like the idea that he will be scapegoated. This season is firmly on David Lee and the front office.

whether you have the players or not, there are basic things that nick just did not do well. there are teams with worse talent who played with more personality than us. we had no ideas, patterns of play, or consistency in the starting lineup to really get some gelling going on. not to mention, under nick, we seem to drop our line of confrontation well into our half instead of pressing much higher in the attacking third to force turnovers.

with a strong midfield that we have, we should be able to do this. even if we don't do it well at first, it should be something that is drilled and worked on and even untalented players can learn how to press with some effectiveness (look at red bull).

yet - nick continues to field a different team nearly every game. rotation maybe? but none of these players have played enough straight games to truly deserve /need a rotation except for parks - who just happens to be the only consistent name in the starting xi. how do you expect a team to perform with cohesion and flow if they aren't allowed to get used to each other?

having new players so late in the season is difficult. but nick has showed that he doesn't know what to work with what he's got either. maybe none of these players were what he wanted. but he doesn't have the courage to bitch about it like dome cause he's a company man. maybe that's why he keeps his job or gets sent back to europe for some other position in CFG.

no, it's not easy to play with a team that had its spine ripped out, no striker, and then getting all new players with a 3rd of the season left to go where the first 2/3rd of the season just didn't go well. but regardless of the roster, i personally think a good coach should be able to implement certain patterns of play and inspire his players. whether those patterns of play work or not, that's one thing. but we don't even see any of it. what we do see is a lot of negative passes, slow decision making (cause we don't know where others will be - again no patterns of play), and jogging around the field like it's a rec league game. maxi is 35 years old and he was outrunning most everyone on out team tonight. that's just pathetic.

yes the front office dropped the ball. but nick is not being scape goated.. he's just not head coach material.