And so we come to the end of a wonderful campaign! 25 People started on the island, and though we saw an unprecedented number of ties and tribalism from the voters, we've come out with a clear winner at the top! I want to thank everyone who participated this series and really made it fun to check back and try to get certain people voted off / saved. That's what survivor is all about!
Without further adieu, our Series 6 winner, Matt Freese!:
In second place, moving from third to second place, Alonso Martinez!
In this place on debut, Nico Fernandez Mercau! (insert non-existent gif here)
Definitive NYCFC Player Ranking Based On ~24 People On a Forum (Last year player ranked here, displacement to this year's ranking*)
(1): Matt Freese (Maxi Moralez, -7) Last Year: 2, +1
(2): Alonso Martínez (Matt Freese, +1) Last Year: 3, +1
(3): Nicolás Fernández Mercau (Alonso Martinez, +1) Last Year: Debut
(5): Kevin O'Toole (Santiago Rodriguez, N/A) Last Year: 10, +5
(5): Tayvon Gray (Tayvon Gray, SAME) Last Year: 5, SAME
(6): Andrés Perea (Andrés Perea, SAME) Last Year: 6, SAME
(8): Maxi Moralez (Malachi Jones, N/A) Last Year: 1, -7
(8): Jonathan Shore (Justin Haak, -8) Last Year: Debut
(10): Thiago Martins (Keaton Parks, SAME) Last Year: 13, +3
(10): Keaton Parks (Kevin O'Toole, +5) Last Year: 9, -1
(13): Seymour Reid (Hannes Wolf, SAME) Last Year: Debut
(13): Aiden O'Neill (Mitja Ilenič, -8) Last Year: Debut
(13): Hannes Wolf (Thiago Martins, +3) Last Year: 11, -2
(14): Raul Gustavo (James Sands, N/A) Last Year: Debut
(15): Máximo Carrizo (Christian McFarlane, N/A) Last Year: Debut
(16): Agustin Ojeda (Julián Fernández, -8) Last Year: 24, +8
(17): Justin Haak (Birk Risa, -3) Last Year: 9, -8
(18): Nico Cavallo (Luis Barraza, N/A) Last Year: Debut
(19): Tomas Romero (Talles Magno, N/A) Last Year: Debut
(20): Birk Risa (Strahinja Tanasijević, -2) Last Year: 17, -3
(21): Mitja Ilenič (Andres Jasson, N/A) Last Year: 12, -8
(22): Strahinja Tanasijević (Monsef Bakrar, -2) Last Year: 20, -2
(24): Julián Fernández (Jovan Mijatović, N/A) Last Year: 16, -8 - Congrats on the shared wooden spoon!
(24): Monsef Bakrar (Agustin Ojeda, +8) Last Year: 22, -2 - Congrats on the shared wooden spoon!
* Some players tied last year, and as such the displacement will reflect based on the tie, but the players will show up on following rows anyway. The displacement will still be calculated based on the actual numbers, though.
2025 Off-season Biggest Winners: Kevin O'Toole +5, Alonso Martinez +1 (stays in top 3 for a second series)
2025 Off-season Biggest Improvement: Kevin O'Toole +5 (worth noting last series he was in 10th off of a +11 spot jump, so this is +16 spots to top 5 within two series where he was pretty far down), Agustin Ojeda +8
2025 Off-season Biggest Losers: Mitja Ilenic -8, Julian Fernandez -8, Justin Haak -8, Maxi Moralez -7 (worth noting that each of these players has a drop that makes sense
This season we saw an unprecedented 4 same position stays and some of the rankings really didn't change much. I'm curious on what sort of sentiment that shows about the opinions on this forum about certain players or our season.
Until next off-season, it's been fun! Thanks everyone for participating.
Without further adieu, our Series 6 winner, Matt Freese!:
In second place, moving from third to second place, Alonso Martinez!
In this place on debut, Nico Fernandez Mercau! (insert non-existent gif here)
Definitive NYCFC Player Ranking Based On ~24 People On a Forum (Last year player ranked here, displacement to this year's ranking*)
(1): Matt Freese (Maxi Moralez, -7) Last Year: 2, +1
(2): Alonso Martínez (Matt Freese, +1) Last Year: 3, +1
(3): Nicolás Fernández Mercau (Alonso Martinez, +1) Last Year: Debut
(5): Kevin O'Toole (Santiago Rodriguez, N/A) Last Year: 10, +5
(5): Tayvon Gray (Tayvon Gray, SAME) Last Year: 5, SAME
(6): Andrés Perea (Andrés Perea, SAME) Last Year: 6, SAME
(8): Maxi Moralez (Malachi Jones, N/A) Last Year: 1, -7
(8): Jonathan Shore (Justin Haak, -8) Last Year: Debut
(10): Thiago Martins (Keaton Parks, SAME) Last Year: 13, +3
(10): Keaton Parks (Kevin O'Toole, +5) Last Year: 9, -1
(13): Seymour Reid (Hannes Wolf, SAME) Last Year: Debut
(13): Aiden O'Neill (Mitja Ilenič, -8) Last Year: Debut
(13): Hannes Wolf (Thiago Martins, +3) Last Year: 11, -2
(14): Raul Gustavo (James Sands, N/A) Last Year: Debut
(15): Máximo Carrizo (Christian McFarlane, N/A) Last Year: Debut
(16): Agustin Ojeda (Julián Fernández, -8) Last Year: 24, +8
(17): Justin Haak (Birk Risa, -3) Last Year: 9, -8
(18): Nico Cavallo (Luis Barraza, N/A) Last Year: Debut
(19): Tomas Romero (Talles Magno, N/A) Last Year: Debut
(20): Birk Risa (Strahinja Tanasijević, -2) Last Year: 17, -3
(21): Mitja Ilenič (Andres Jasson, N/A) Last Year: 12, -8
(22): Strahinja Tanasijević (Monsef Bakrar, -2) Last Year: 20, -2
(24): Julián Fernández (Jovan Mijatović, N/A) Last Year: 16, -8 - Congrats on the shared wooden spoon!
(24): Monsef Bakrar (Agustin Ojeda, +8) Last Year: 22, -2 - Congrats on the shared wooden spoon!
* Some players tied last year, and as such the displacement will reflect based on the tie, but the players will show up on following rows anyway. The displacement will still be calculated based on the actual numbers, though.
2025 Off-season Biggest Winners: Kevin O'Toole +5, Alonso Martinez +1 (stays in top 3 for a second series)
2025 Off-season Biggest Improvement: Kevin O'Toole +5 (worth noting last series he was in 10th off of a +11 spot jump, so this is +16 spots to top 5 within two series where he was pretty far down), Agustin Ojeda +8
2025 Off-season Biggest Losers: Mitja Ilenic -8, Julian Fernandez -8, Justin Haak -8, Maxi Moralez -7 (worth noting that each of these players has a drop that makes sense
This season we saw an unprecedented 4 same position stays and some of the rankings really didn't change much. I'm curious on what sort of sentiment that shows about the opinions on this forum about certain players or our season.
Until next off-season, it's been fun! Thanks everyone for participating.
