Old New York City Soccer Teams Of The Past

JCizzle

Registered
Nov 18, 2014
252
186
43
New Yorkers have been playing soccer for almost 140 years with regional leagues forming in the 1880's. By the early 1900s, newspapers were beginning to call it soccer (or "soccer" football, as in this article). Here are a few of the more interesting names of organized soccer teams from New York City over the many years:

New York Thistles -- played from the early 1880s until 1906. Among their colorfully named competition in those years were the Brooklyn Longfellows, the New York Caledonians, New York Nonpareils and the Williamsburg Shamrocks.

New York Hakoah -- The original Hakoah (Hebrew for 'strength') played in New York during in the 1920s, derived from a Jewish Austrian sports club of the same name. (It eventually derived many of its players from the Austrian team too.) Several players inducted into the National Soccer Hall of Fame played for the Hakoah at one point. There is presently a team by this name keeping up the tradition in New Jersey.

New York Americans -- This patriotic team formed by Hungarian player Emo Schwarz entertained audiences during the Great Depression, along with the New York Brookhattan. In the 1950s, they actually merged with another team to form a second incarnation of the New York Hakoah.

New York Skyliners -- Playing all their games at Yankee Stadium, the New York Skyliners were a curious aberration that lasted only a single season (1967), giving New York two professional soccer teams (the other being the New York Generals). Nobody on the team was from New York; they were simply the (briefly) rebranded Cerro team from Montevideo, Uruguay. By the end of 1968, both the Generals and the Skyliners had folded.

New York Cosmos -- Soccer made a serious push to rival baseball and football in the United States in the 1970s, and New York's entrant into this new spotlight were the Cosmos, who played from 1971 to 1984. In late 1970s, at the height of their popularity, they were packing 40,000 people per game into Giants Stadium, thanks in part to their star player Pelé (pictured above). Sadly, the excitement for soccer waned in the 1980s. The North American Soccer League folded, as did the Cosmos.

There's also a host of one-shot names that cropped up in old "soccer" football records between 1860 and 1880s. From that list, I'd like to offer up the following names -- New York Married & Singles, New York Dauntless, New York Gentlemen, New York Pilgrims and the New York Westside Rovers.

Of course, if there is a new name, it will probably be a product of some sort. But at least make it a New York-based product please! The New York Snapples? The New York Katzs'? The New York Shake Shacks?
http://theboweryboys.blogspot.com/2013/05/go-thistles-finest-names-from-old-nyc.html
 
  • Like
Reactions: einwindir

Gene

Registered
Donor
Mar 19, 2014
3,408
4,234
353
Down & Out
There were several other teams too that played in the old American Soccer League. The New York Apollo, New York United and the New York Centaurs.

The Centaurs played on Randalls Island.

United was in the 'burbs and I kind of recall it may have been Mt. Vernon, but don't hold my feet to the fire on that one.

The Apollo was around for years, but quite honestly I can't recall where their home field was. I wonder if it was out at Hofstra?
 
  • Like
Reactions: einwindir

Fantazma

Registered
Seasoned Supporter
Nov 9, 2014
8,242
9,705
303
New York Skyliners -- Playing all their games at Yankee Stadium, the New York Skyliners were a curious aberration that lasted only a single season (1967), giving New York two professional soccer teams (the other being the New York Generals). Nobody on the team was from New York; they were simply the (briefly) rebranded Cerro team from Montevideo, Uruguay. By the end of 1968, both the Generals and the Skyliners had folded.

http://theboweryboys.blogspot.com/2013/05/go-thistles-finest-names-from-old-nyc.html

Wasnt this team part of some made up league that were teams brought from abroad and just had names changed. I think it eventually merged to what would become the first NASL?

This is good info and there are still clubs that play at the amateur level, id like to know more of the cities former/current teams. I only get so much from the internet.

Also maybe someday down the line they can come up with a throwback jersey for one of the teams kinda of how the Philadelphia Union did.
 

JCizzle

Registered
Nov 18, 2014
252
186
43
Throwback sounds pretty cool. Maybe in time. I think in a year they will first tweek the home jersey. As much as I like Man City, they will need more of their own identity.
 
  • Like
Reactions: einwindir