That's another hit.
Suspended 1 game by disciplinary committee.
Suspended 1 game by disciplinary committee.
Saunders Suspended
- Thread starter NYCFC_Dan
- Start date
http://www.mlssoccer.com/video/2015...nge-ishamel-yartey-mls-disciplinary-committee
The only thing I like about this video is that I see myself applauding from the bleachers after the save
The only thing I like about this video is that I see myself applauding from the bleachers after the save
Studs up into the shins/knees? At least he got his money's worth for the punishment. GK is one place where we have good backups. Not too concerned about this.
In case you're curious, the rules governing post-match review: http://www.mlssoccer.com/mls-disciplinary-committee-principles-parameters
Over on BigSoccer, they have an annual thread following all of the Disciplinary Committee (DisCo) decisions. Many of the decisions and non-decisions often baffle many of us, but they do often get it right.
Not arguing that they have been consistent, just sharing the rules that purportedly govern how/why they issue post-match suspensions. For Saunders, the referee saw it and didn't take any action. That's why in the disciplinary opinion notes that it was unanimous. Apparently they unanimously agreed that the video showed "a clear and unequivocal" red card.
I'm still fairly new to MLS, so someone with more expertise feel free to correct me, but of the games I have watched so far this season (including, but not limited to NYCFC matches) there have been some pretty heavy handed calls. Saunders is the first post-match disciplinary action I have seen this season, but perhaps there have been other incidents (I could only find an MLS page only shows current disciplinary matters, not one that shows cumulatively what has happened this season). Are MLS players really that much more egregious and reckless in nature that there are many more straight reds than other leagues? Or does it have to do with the refereeing? My hunch is the latter. But again, I could be wrong.
FWIW, after watching the Saunders video a second time, I hadn't noticed that his right foot/studs were up so high. Definitely didn't notice it from behind the goal when I was at the game
Edit: 4 413Blue can you link to the thread? I only found Week 1 info
Last edited:
On the bottom of the article, it links to each weeks DisCo action from this season. There have been a couple of retroactive suspensions so far.
http://www.mlssoccer.com/news/artic...s-new-york-city-fc-goalkeeper-josh-saunders-o
http://forums.bigsoccer.com/threads/official-2015-mls-disco-discussion.2017472/
Not the first time this season that Saunders seems to momentarily forget he can use his hands. Anyone remember the home game where he randomly cleared a cross with his legs? Can't remember which one. Guy gives me a heart attack at least once a game.
That said, this retroactive suspension stuff is bullshit. I'm not even sure it's a foul myself.
That said, this retroactive suspension stuff is bullshit. I'm not even sure it's a foul myself.
I'm new too that's why asked. But i do believe it felt like it was "arguable" not "clear cut" but we'll see how our back up will do.
Still this is another blow to an already depleted team.
