Stadium Discussion

Where Do You Want The Stadium?

  • Manhattan

    Votes: 54 16.6%
  • Queens

    Votes: 99 30.5%
  • Brooklyn

    Votes: 19 5.8%
  • Staten Island

    Votes: 7 2.2%
  • Westchester

    Votes: 18 5.5%
  • The Bronx

    Votes: 113 34.8%
  • Long Island

    Votes: 7 2.2%
  • Dual-Boroughs

    Votes: 3 0.9%
  • Etihad Island

    Votes: 5 1.5%

  • Total voters
    325
This thread is always fun to come back to after a few days. I've learned so much.

I never knew about The Singer Bowl and I grew up and lived in Corona and Flushing.
Louis Armstrong is getting a retractable roof too? Ridiculous.
Building a brand new pier would be dope but also super expensive, like hundreds of millions.

I still think our best and most likely site is the Bronx site, the team had/has a plan for it already, I'm sure they've mocked up some designs we haven't seen and there would be little protest (relative to everywhere else) considering there is a stadium there already.

What's really disappointing is that the people in this thread (I love you all) seem to have more enthusiasm for building a stadium than the team does. There's so many steps to come before we can get to the point where it's a realistic possibility and I have no reason to believe they've taken any of them. From speaking to local elected officials, community boards, or even filing some of the several hundred documents they'd need with the city.

It'll be 3 years in December since the original Bronx site was shot down. 3 years with no real development. Sure, they've started working together with the city which is a great sign for the future, but no one has said anything other than a generic "we're committed to working with the city" statement.

So I'm a bit disappointed, I hope the team makes some sort of statement or at least gets the ball rolling before the end of the year. Not only do we have to acquire the land, we'd have to get clearance from all appropriate agencies, as well as demolition before we start building, even then it'll be at least 2 years from that point, maybe more.

Orlando's Stadium broke ground in 2014 and will be open in 2017.
RBA broke ground in 2006 and was opened in 2010.
PPL Park broke ground in 2008 and opened in 2010.

Even if we look at a scenario where everything is expedited and cut things down to the bare minimum amount of time we'd need: we announce purchase of the GAL site today, getting the city and community on board with the plans takes 6 months, demolition and construction takes 2 1/2 - 3 years, we're in our own stadium in time for 2020, maybe halfway through 2019.

Now realistically, add at least a year to every one of those steps and we won't see our own home until 2021-2025. Who knows, between now and then we might have a stadium big enough to host games for the 2026 World Cup.
 
  • Like
Reactions: adam and Kjbert
Let's just cut through all of the red tape and have the S.S. Etihad Liner. It'll be a monsterous luxury liner with a stadium on top - kind of a cross between a jumbo freighter, cruise liner, and pirate ship. Spectators can't be late for kickoff because once it embarks, it cruises up/down/around Manhattan on the rivers. It would give ever-changing views of all the NYC landmarks. Score a goal - the booming fog horn blows. Opponent gets a red card - he walks the plank. Games played rain or shine and during tropical storms - the ultimate home field advantage when the waves roll high and the ship bobs up/down - let's see RB commit to a high press as they're puking their guts out with sea sickness. Want to tailgate, the ship has 7 bars scattered throughout the decks along with a casino. Post game pressers are in the theatre followed by nightcap performances of cirque du soleil. Need to leave early, cue up at the launch and take a rubber zodiac to the nearest ferry terminal (for an extra fee).

It isn't Etihad Island, it's better! We're mobile!!!
 
Wasn't Dinkins arrested for hitting a pedestrian while driving recently?

Also Dante, de Blasio's son loves NYCFC, so that should be a damn good motivator to get us a stadium.
my god no! if political decisions were made because of a non-elected family member's preferences, that is not a world I want to live in even if it benefits me.
 
Let's just cut through all of the red tape and have the S.S. Etihad Liner. It'll be a monsterous luxury liner with a stadium on top - kind of a cross between a jumbo freighter, cruise liner, and pirate ship. Spectators can't be late for kickoff because once it embarks, it cruises up/down/around Manhattan on the rivers. It would give ever-changing views of all the NYC landmarks. Score a goal - the booming fog horn blows. Opponent gets a red card - he walks the plank. Games played rain or shine and during tropical storms - the ultimate home field advantage when the waves roll high and the ship bobs up/down - let's see RB commit to a high press as they're puking their guts out with sea sickness. Want to tailgate, the ship has 7 bars scattered throughout the decks along with a casino. Post game pressers are in the theatre followed by nightcap performances of cirque du soleil. Need to leave early, cue up at the launch and take a rubber zodiac to the nearest ferry terminal (for an extra fee).

It isn't Etihad Island, it's better! We're mobile!!!

Page 100 buddy. And the real problem with that idea, as I mentioned over 200 pages ago, is if we get too good they will just sail is back to Manchester to play there!

EDIT: This forum old-timer (wow, I can't believe I'm calling myself that) forgot to add the link to the page. http://nycfcforums.com/index.php?threads/stadium-discussion.21/page-100

Also, what the hell ever happened to Drainyoo ?
 
Last edited:
Page 100 buddy. And the real problem with that idea, as I mentioned over 200 pages ago, is if we get too good they will just sail is back to Manchester to play there!
Until the intern makes the Table of Contents & Glossery, I plead ignorance as pg100 was before my time on the forums.

And my pirate ship/liner is cooler.
 
Would Randalls and Wards Islands really be that bad? I bet we could get that going in a jiffy.
Would be a 100% no go. If there's no transit it's not happening.

Though worth mentioning that last year I was told that NYCFC has a good percentage of STHs in Westchester and Connecticut. I didn't think too much of it until this week.

Considering they're doing a combined BX/Westchester City in the Boroughs session and didn't do anything for Long Island, this probably means that it's not an insignificant number and they want to keep their season ticket holding fans in Westchester and CT happy.

So with that in mind (DISCLAIMER: THE FOLLOWING IS SPECULATION) you can probably rule out any stadium location that doesn't have direct, or at least easy access to a Metro North line.

The Bronx site has a station there, and the LIC site is a short train/ferry ride away from Grand Central.

So at this point you can scratch Brooklyn, and most of Queens from the map. Lets be real, no one even considered Staten Island. So We're looking at most likely, the Bronx or if they can find land, Upper Manhattan.
 
Considering they're doing a combined BX/Westchester City in the Boroughs session and didn't do anything for Long Island, this probably means that it's not an insignificant number and they want to keep their season ticket holding fans in Westchester and CT happy.
As one of the 29% who voted for Queens in this thread's poll, that sir, is bullshit!!

(though probably right, damnit)
 
Would be a 100% no go. If there's no transit it's not happening.

Though worth mentioning that last year I was told that NYCFC has a good percentage of STHs in Westchester and Connecticut. I didn't think too much of it until this week.

Considering they're doing a combined BX/Westchester City in the Boroughs session and didn't do anything for Long Island, this probably means that it's not an insignificant number and they want to keep their season ticket holding fans in Westchester and CT happy.

So with that in mind (DISCLAIMER: THE FOLLOWING IS SPECULATION) you can probably rule out any stadium location that doesn't have direct, or at least easy access to a Metro North line.

The Bronx site has a station there, and the LIC site is a short train/ferry ride away from Grand Central.

So at this point you can scratch Brooklyn, and most of Queens from the map. Lets be real, no one even considered Staten Island. So We're looking at most likely, the Bronx or if they can find land, Upper Manhattan.

So it's the original Bronx site or Columbia Athletics campus...
 
Would be a 100% no go. If there's no transit it's not happening.

Though worth mentioning that last year I was told that NYCFC has a good percentage of STHs in Westchester and Connecticut. I didn't think too much of it until this week.

Considering they're doing a combined BX/Westchester City in the Boroughs session and didn't do anything for Long Island, this probably means that it's not an insignificant number and they want to keep their season ticket holding fans in Westchester and CT happy.

So with that in mind (DISCLAIMER: THE FOLLOWING IS SPECULATION) you can probably rule out any stadium location that doesn't have direct, or at least easy access to a Metro North line.

The Bronx site has a station there, and the LIC site is a short train/ferry ride away from Grand Central.

So at this point you can scratch Brooklyn, and most of Queens from the map. Lets be real, no one even considered Staten Island. So We're looking at most likely, the Bronx or if they can find land, Upper Manhattan.
Point of information..... just because there hasn't been a LI City in the Boroughs doesn't mean there won't be one. They're spacing them out quite a bit so there's always a possibility that the next one could be LI (or even SI).
 
If they're not building the stadium in LIC (which is possible based on some of the things I've been reading recently and learned a few months ago pointing back to the original Bronx site -- Including De Blasio getting so warm with the club in recent months), based on what I've been told, they're definitely building something there. Perhaps the training facility/academy base?

In any case, all evidence for me right now is pointing to the stadium being in either LIC or the GAL Bronx site (I'm starting to lean more towards this now). If it's somewhere else, it would be a quite a surprise to me.
 
Non-NYCFC stadium info.

I heard an interesting bit of insider info today about the Cosmos stadium situation. There is a (obviously) a major hold up in the Cosmos Belmont plans...drum roll... the Islanders. It's no secret that the Islanders have had a bit of a rough start to their time at Barclays and allegedly have an out clause in the first few years to run from Barclays Center. Nassau city officials have pretty much said that they don't want the Isles back and have reduced the seats of the new Coliseum enough that it no longer meets NHL standards.

The word on the street is that ELMONT is at the top of the Islanders list for relocations. IF that actually happened, it would kill the Cosmos stadium plan. Obviously the city would rather have a well established Islanders team than a struggling Cosmos team.

If Cosmos can't get that stadium built, that's probably the end of the road for them, and possibly the NASL.

*As with everything in this thread, to be taken with a grain of salt.
 
Last edited:
Non-NYCFC stadium info.

I heard an interesting bit of insider info today about the Cosmos stadium situation. There is a (obviously) a major hold up in the Cosmos Belmont plans...drum roll... the Islanders. It's no secret that the Islanders have had a bit of a rough start to their time at Barclays. They allegedly have an out clause in the first few years to run from Barclays Center. Nassau city officials have pretty much said that they don't want the Isles back. They've reduced the seats of the new Coliseum enough that it no longer meets NHL standards.

The world on the street is that ELMONT is at the top of the Islanders list for relocations. IF that actually happened, it would kill the Cosmos stadium plan. Obviously the city would rather have a well established Islanders team than a struggling Cosmos team.

If Cosmos can't get that stadium built, that's probably the end of the road for them, and possibly the NASL.

*As with everything in this thread, to be taken with a grain of salt.
If not Elmont, do the Islanders have really any other viable locations??? Because that's a no-brainer to award the site to them over a middling b-rate soccer team. I wonder how long the state can realistically hold up awarding the site before the Kosmos file some form of litigation against the state?
 
  • Like
Reactions: Kjbert
If they're not building the stadium in LIC (which is possible based on some of the things I've been reading recently and learned a few months ago pointing back to the original Bronx site -- Including De Blasio getting so warm with the club in recent months), based on what I've been told, they're definitely building something there. Perhaps the training facility/academy base?

In any case, all evidence for me right now is pointing to the stadium being in either LIC or the GAL Bronx site (I'm starting to lean more towards this now). If it's somewhere else, it would be a quite a surprise to me.

Maybe a smaller stadium for NYCFCII and potentially NYCWFC