City vs. Atlas... U Pick!

[Gotham Gator]

This is our Pick 'em Thread. Pick the following.

• score
• the goalscorers, in order
• the POTM (Pigeon of the Match)

The contestant picking the correct result (win, lose, draw) and coming closest to the actual score wins a Mug of Ale from me should we ever meet and his/her name permanently enshrined in the Hall of Victory!

Good Luck!

Tiebreakers, in order...
(1) correct result (win, lose, draw)*
(2) closest to the actual score
(3) correctly naming the most goalscorers
(4) correct goalscoring order (by team)
* - a player cannot win by picking a win if the result is a loss (and vice versa)

GIF of the Game

Hall of Victory!
NSH - @

ALBNYfan
CHI - @

Gotham Gator
MIA - @

Sabo
DCU - @

Gotham Gator
HOU - Gene
NER - JayH
ATL - Gotham Gator
NSH - JCMore
DAL - 4 413Blue
TOR - JCMore
CLT - Jon
CIN - Gene
NJR - M canchon & LionNYC
ORL - Gene
PHI - canchon
CIN - JCMore
NER - canchon
SLC - Gene
CLB - JCMore
ATL - Gotham Gator
POR - Gene
MTL - JCMore
CHL - LionNYC
CLB - @JMore
PHI - Kenny

 

[mgarbowski]

1-1
Sands, Lozano
Atlas wins PKs 5-3.

 

[Brooklyn Blue]

7-0

 

[Shwafta]

1-1
Sands, Lozano
Atlas wins PKs 5-3.

isn't this almost what happened when we played pumas the other year? lol

 

[Shwafta]

2-1 NYCFC
New guy x 2
some random atlas dude

 

[mgarbowski]

isn't this almost what happened when we played pumas the other year? lolView attachment 12899

Close enough.

 

[Kenny]

0-0

Edit: NYCFC wins on PKs

 

[mgarbowski]

Gotham Gator clarification please?
You don't mention shootouts in the instructions. Are they irrelevant even as a tiebreaker?

 

[Gotham Gator]

Gotham Gator clarification please?
You don't mention shootouts in the instructions. Are they irrelevant even as a tiebreaker?

Good point. Need to consider this one.

How about a rule that all score predictions are measured against the end of regulation (plus extra time, if applicable). If the game is tied and goes to penalties, the first tiebreaker is correctly guessing the winner in penalties. Then, we go through our usual tiebreakers.

 

[mgarbowski]

Good point. Need to consider this one.

How about a rule that all score predictions are measured against the end of regulation (plus extra time, if applicable). If the game is tied and goes to penalties, the first tiebreaker is correctly guessing the winner in penalties. Then, we go through our usual tiebreakers.

That's fine with me. In fact any non-bizarro rules you choose are fine with me. I just figure it's better to set them in advance.

 

[CCMore]

2-0

Taty
Gabi

... oh wait.

 

[mgarbowski]

New prediction
0-0
Atlas wins shootout 1-0 in the ninth round.

https://twitter.com/x/status/1682476151426433024

 

[moogoo]

New prediction
0-0
Atlas wins shootout 1-0 in the ninth round.

https://twitter.com/x/status/1682476151426433024

so TFC are going to win this group and it'll be a battle between shit and shittier for the 2nd position. lol

 

[413Blue]

NYC 3-0 Atlas

Heber
Thiago
Pereira

 

[LionNYC]

Atlas 1 - NYCFC 0

 

[Gotham Gator]

Atlas 3
NYC 0

POTM: Pereira

 

[Gene]

My feeling is the match is going to be a snoozefest. So, with that guarantee being made the obvious winning prediction will be:

NYCFC: 4
Atlas: 3

Atlas: 3 guys, because I don't know who's on their roster.
NYCFC: 4 guys, because I don't know who's on their roster.

 

[JayH]

Atlas: 3 guys, because I don't know who's on their roster.
NYCFC: 4 guys, because I don't know who's on their roster.

 

[Gotham Gator]

Atlas 1 - NYCFC 0

Winner.