Home - 7/14 Columbus

[Ulrich]

Has anyone seen a report whether Villa practiced with the team yesterday or today? He was training onsite but by himself Monday or Tuesday, I forget which. Given that, I doubt he is ready for 90. I can see him available as a sub, if he trained with the team after Wednesday, and I see no reason not to use him if he is available.

Also, per Butler's twitter, Berget was upgraded to "Questionable."

https://twitter.com/x/status/1017803379194650625

I doubt he plays, but this should mean he is progressing well.

For NYCFC, questionable, amounts to Dome asking the trainer if the player can play, and the Trainer responds, No.

I don’t think we’ve ever had a player listed as Questionable actually play. Maybe ride the 18, but that’s it.

 

[Gotham Gator]

Has anyone seen a report whether Villa practiced with the team yesterday or today? He was training onsite but by himself Monday or Tuesday, I forget which. Given that, I doubt he is ready for 90. I can see him available as a sub, if he trained with the team after Wednesday, and I see no reason not to use him if he is available.

Also, per Butler's twitter, Berget was upgraded to "Questionable."

https://twitter.com/x/status/1017803379194650625

I doubt he plays, but this should mean he is progressing well.

When I saw this tweet from Butler, I was waiting for the NY Presbyterian Injury Report - still waiting.

 

[mgarbowski]

For NYCFC, questionable, amounts to Dome asking the trainer if the player can play, and the Trainer responds, No.

I don’t think we’ve ever had a player listed as Questionable actually play. Maybe ride the 18, but that’s it.

Villa was listed as Questionable for RSL and played 31 minutes.
https://matchcenter.mlssoccer.com/matchcenter/2018-04-11-new-york-city-fc-vs-real-salt-lake/preview

I expect I could find more. My sense is the club uses Questionable status as a warehouse for most injured players. Transitioning someone from Questionable to Likely gives unnecessary information to the opponent.

 

[Ulrich]

Villa was listed as Questionable for RSL and played 31 minutes.
https://matchcenter.mlssoccer.com/matchcenter/2018-04-11-new-york-city-fc-vs-real-salt-lake/preview

I expect I could find more. My sense is the club uses Questionable status as a warehouse for most injured players. Transitioning someone from Questionable to Likely gives unnecessary information to the opponent.

I stand corrected.

Would love to see Berget ready to go tomorrow.

 

[Seven]

For NYCFC, questionable, amounts to Dome asking the trainer if the player can play, and the Trainer responds, No.

I don’t think we’ve ever had a player listed as Questionable actually play. Maybe ride the 18, but that’s it.

Mata was listed as questionable for Wednesday and came on as a sub

ETA: Whoops, probably should have actually read all the responses before I answered the same question

 

[canchon]

When I saw this tweet from Butler, I was waiting for the NY Presbyterian Injury Report - still waiting.

I thought great things were happening there. Guess printing the injury report isn’t one of them.

 

[canchon]

So two things I got from reading the match preview:

1. CLB crosses the ball a ton (two of their players are leading the league in crosses). Chanot would be a good call to deal with that.

2. CLB has scored more than 40% of their goals on set pieces. Oh no.

 

[LionNYC]

So two things I got from reading the match preview:

1. CLB crosses the ball a ton (two of their players are leading the league in crosses). Chanot would be a good call to deal with that.

2. CLB has scored more than 40% of their goals on set pieces. Oh no.

1. That's why Seb played on Wednesday, so Chanot could rest.

2. That's why we aren't doing zonal marking anymore.

 

[Gotham Gator]

I thought great things were happening there. Guess printing the injury report isn’t one of them.

It's "Amazing things are happening here" - and as the good Mrs. Dr. Gotham reports, the residents at NYP like to say that they left out the comma after the first word - as in "Amazing, things are happening here."

 

[The Toe]

INJURY REPORT



NYCFC:



OUT: M - Yangel Herrera (Ankle)

OUT: D - Cedric Hountondji (Hamstring)

QUESTIONABLE: F - Jo Inge Berget (Quad)

QUESTIONABLE: F - Isi Tajouri-Shradi (Hamstring)

QUESTIONABLE: F - David Villa (Knee)


COLUMBUS CREW SC:


OUT: M - Mohammed Abu (Thigh)
OUT: F - Adam Jahn (Knee)

QUESTIONABLE: D - Jonathan Mensah (Concussion)

 

[Kjbert]

Totally different definition this year than year's past in the definition of questionable it appears

 

[Midas Mulligan]

Heads up if you’re counting on the D. It’s wack.

Been waiting for a half hour in Manhattan. Must be seriously reduced service.