2018 Offseason Thread

I think a bigger deal that Haak, Shavar, Polvara, and Scally are there too. I don't know much about the last two, but Haak and Shaver are legit with the USBNT. Maybe it's just PV giving them a taste of what's next, or they're being used as a litmus test for the drafted players to be compared to, but to have brought 5 guys total says something that about the state of the academy.
Trades are great, but it's our homegrowns and draft picks that I really want to see succeed. We seem to have a real competitive advantage in scouting. Likewise, we can and should beat the league on development.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Sabo
Who has the largest population to draw from in the league? I think RSL has the largest square area to pull from. Do we have the most population to pull from?
 
https://www.nycfc.com/post/2018/01/22/preseason-2018-31-players-travel-jacksonville

Goalkeepers: Andre Rawls, Jeff Caldwell^, Sean Johnson, Brad Stuver

Defenders: Anton Tinnerholm, Saad Abdul-Salaam, Joe Scally^^, Maxime Chanot, Sebastian Ibeagha*, Ryan Felix*, Tyler Shaver^^, Ronald Matarrita, Ben Sweat, AJ Paterson^, Alex Bumpus^, Alex Callens

Midfielders: Alex Ring, James Sands, Yangel Herrera, Tommy McNamara, Kwame Awuah, Maxi Moralez, Justin Haak^^, Dante Polvara^^, Gio Reyna^^

Forwards: Jack Harrison, Jonathan Lewis, David Villa, Rodney Wallace, Jesus Medina, Andre Fortune*

^ Unsigned 2018 MLS SuperDraft pick
* Trialist
^^ Academy Player

Sebastian Ibeagha - USL Defender of the Year 2017, San Antonio FC
Ryan Felix - Rochester Rhinos
Andre Fortune II - Rochester Rhinos
Ibeagha could be interesting. On the one hand, Ugo was tearing shit up in USL, and Ibeagha had a chance at Houston and presumably didn't pass muster. On the other hand, PV and staff have shown they can drastically improve defenders (Sweat, White), so he could be a prospect.

Side note: I remember seeing Sweat in pre-season and thinking he was getting torched but he was really solid by the tail end.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Ulrich
Ibeagha could be interesting. On the one hand, Ugo was tearing shit up in USL, and Ibeagha had a chance at Houston and presumably didn't pass muster. On the other hand, PV and staff have shown they can drastically improve defenders (Sweat, White), so he could be a prospect.

Side note: I remember seeing Sweat in pre-season and thinking he was getting torched but he was really solid by the tail end.

Ibeagha being on our preseason roster is the only thing that our USL affiliate connection to San Antonio did good for us. We didn’t loan any players to them last year. It was just a handshake and two or three social media posts connections. At least, their best denfense player was put on our preseason roster.

Honestly, we’ll probably sign him if we looks a good bench option and agree to sign a low, low contract.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Kjbert
Chicago did re-sign Schweini, gonna be tough to get out of our group
There are 6 playoff spots and the only reason the standing were close last year was because of massive injuries (leading to bullshit lineups with the two slowest players on the team in midfield) and PV’s insistence on bad substitutions (either trying to bunker when we aren’t built to or bringing in inadequately skilled players like Shelton). If the depth we’ve accumulated is as good as being advertised and suspected, then there shouldn’t be a dramatic drop off when replacing injuries and going to the bench. The only caveat is if PV still thinks TMac is a better option than every other player on the roster - that happens and we’ll be playing with 10+1 traffic cop.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Fake Jew and adam
No worries. We don’t have to play Trinidad.
giphy.gif
 
I think a bigger deal that Haak, Shavar, Polvara, and Scally are there too. I don't know much about the last two, but Haak and Shaver are legit with the USBNT. Maybe it's just PV giving them a taste of what's next, or they're being used as a litmus test for the drafted players to be compared to, but to have brought 5 guys total says something that about the state of the academy.
Actually, I think it says the wrong thing about the club and forthcoming signings. Last year, Sands came alone so it was easy to see it meant something more than what they were letting on.

Bringing 5 just screams means nothing other than training bodies and cover for Gio so no one expects him to actually be signed.
 
Actually, I think it says the wrong thing about the club and forthcoming signings. Last year, Sands came alone so it was easy to see it meant something more than what they were letting on.

Bringing 5 just screams means nothing other than training bodies and cover for Gio so no one expects him to actually be signed.
The smart play seems to be to sign the academy kids before they bypass the Club and sign directly overseas (Weston McKinney). I assumed MLS was going to make some rule changes over the winter to make it easier for clubs to do that, but we won't know if thats the case until the 2018 rules are posted.

PV was talking about having 2 full squads for those back-to-back games. I am expecting that most of the Academy players will get some real minutes and a chance to impress like Sands did.

We are expected to sign Gio if we can.
 
The smart play seems to be to sign the academy kids before they bypass the Club and sign directly overseas (Weston McKinney). I assumed MLS was going to make some rule changes over the winter to make it easier for clubs to do that, but we won't know if thats the case until the 2018 rules are posted.

PV was talking about having 2 full squads for those back-to-back games. I am expecting that most of the Academy players will get some real minutes and a chance to impress like Sands did.

We are expected to sign Gio if we can.
I’m not sure what to take from this, other than McKennie isn’t your favorite player. And yes, people don’t want to miss out on that.

But we don’t have that many kids actually competing for pro deal right now. No way.
 
I’m not sure what to take from this, other than McKennie isn’t your favorite player. And yes, people don’t want to miss out on that.

But we don’t have that many kids actually competing for pro deal right now. No way.
SKC has probably signed 5 in the last 1-2 years. You put the investment into the Academy, you want to make sure its profitable. I don't know how to do that except to get kids under contract and have 1 in 3/4/5? that eventually you can sell on to at least pay for the academy.

Or maybe I was just enjoying the U16s too much last year when they were winning the Generation Adidas Cup. I was impressed the coaches had them playing NYCFC style effectively.
 
2 kids right now are at a level that the club would consider bringing them into the fold.

Ain't happening this spring though. Whoever said they needed bodies to train is spot on. It's also a nice reward and taste of the lifestyle for these kids.