Here is my input with the Capos/No Capos, Drums/No Drums debate.
I think since we could possibly be relatively small when we start, maybe average around 1,500 supporters for the first season (I would love it if we were much bigger, but I am being a bit realistic), it might be feasible to do the No Capos, No Drums method. The problem that Red Bulls Supporters ran into is that sound doesn't travel sideways and backwards at RBA. So if one portion of the section starts singing something, another section doesn't hear them and starts singing something else. If a drum is involved in one of those sections, the other one is completely drowned out. The Capos and drums, in my opinion, would be there to coordinate the different portions of the sections into a unified voice. Not start singing their own songs. Maybe if there is a lull in the atmosphere, they can start to coordinate a song with all the sections.
Since this has never really been done before at Yankee Stadium, I have a feeling that our first season will be a lot of trial and error. We have to see how sound travels out of the bleachers and how we are able to coordinate internally. If we are able to create atmosphere without the Capos and drums, that would be my opinion to carry on. If it isn't working the way we want it, we may have to shift gears and try different things to see what works.
We also have to assume that we will not be the only group of supporters there. I will assume that there will be a Hispanic supporters group with their band style atmosphere. I do not know if there is already one in the works, but I think we should try to absorb them into the Third Rail and try to coordinate something that we can both get behind.
This is just a few of the numerous obstacles we will need to overcome in order to become a successful supporters club. And I am looking forward to every second of it!