Frank Lampard was a more productive player than Pity Martínez was this year and Barco has been since arriving.
Maxi Moralez is better than both of them also.
So what exactly do you want?
You may want to check your stats.
Lampard had 15g/3A over two seasons.
Pity had 9g/5a over one season. And Pity helped deliver the US Open Cup and the Campeones Cup this year. Let’s see what he adds to it next year, but your splitting hairs.
Barco has 8g/5a over two season with another 2A in the CCL, so 8g/7a total
Pirlo had 1g/9a over three seasons.
Villa was the only home run NYCFC landed with their first go at it, and he had 77g/26 over 4 seasons with no hardware earned.
Compare that to Almiron with 21g/28a in two seasons an an MLS Cup championship.
Villa was slightly flashier than Almiron, but hardware is the more important accolade.
And yes, Maxi has better stats than ATL’s current DPs, but he hasn’t delivered a championship of any variety, and his stats are overshadowed by ATL’s non-DP striker Martinez, who’s been instrumental delivering three different championships.
Circling back, that original coin that NYCFC dropped was poorly executed considering the ROI.