NYCFC Players Wanted Thread

In terms of TAM players:

CM
-We definitely need another CM who is at a similar level as Ring, Herrera. We need to have a good squad and the options to rotate, last season Pirlo, TMac played far too many minutes. This allows us to not be overly reliant on our midfield 3 that are often not all available.

Winger
-As well as this we could do with another Winger, looking for someone who is better than Lewis/Wallace. Ideally someone who could play as Striker as well. Signing Ola Kamara would be stupid to say the least considering in the 2 years PV has been manager and when he managed the MCFC EDS he has hardly ever played a 2 striker system. The amount of TAM, GAM we would need to sign him would just not be worth it.

-Our style of play just doesn't work with 4-4-2, maybe if we set up like Barca do with a diamond midfield but we have Harrison and just signed a DP winger so I see this as unlikely, also considering PV has spent the last 2 seasons getting us some actual wingers with pace who are starting quality which he didn't have when he took over.

CB
-On top of this even if Chanot stays we need another CB who is starting quality. Considering Chanot's injury record this is really important.

In terms of non TAM players:

ST
-Obviously we don't have a recognised backup striker so having someone who could come on for Villa late on in matches or come on to partner him would be very useful. Probably looking at a young player who is relatively unproven.

CM/CDM
-Basically looking for a Lopez replacement, maybe use our first round draft pick on this player. We do however have Awuah and Sands but we lost Pirlo, Lopez and Stertzer so we probably need another depth player in this position.
-Someone young, low salary, good enough ability on the ball to play in a possession based system.

CB
-4th choice CB who would play around 5 games, could be a high draft pick(maybe we trade up). Perhaps could go for an experienced player if our TAM CB is young.

That would leave us with 26 players.

ST(2): Villa, non-TAM ST
W(5): Harrison, Medina, TAM W, Wallace, Lewis
CAM(2): Moralez, McNamara
CM/CDM(6): Ring, Herrera, TAM CM, Sands, Awuah, non-TAM CM
CB(4): Callens, Chanot, TAM CB, non-TAM CB
RB(2): Tinnerholm, Abdul-Salaam
LB(2): Matarrita, Sweat
GK (3): Johnson, Stuver, Rawls

Obviously some players can play different positions, having a TAM winger would mean we can rotate them with Harrison, Medina and Moralez for 3 spots and not have a significant drop off in terms of quality.

We would have good enough depth that we can rotate without causing the team to become considerably worse e.g. TMac, RJ Allen etc playing last season.
 
  • Like
Reactions: SoupInNYC
Ring can play as an 8 alongside a less mobile 6. This kid from Holland makes sense. He's strictly a 6 and Maxi is strictly a 10. Ring is a 6 with the ability to play box to box. Herrera is a box to box player. Medina is probably most comfortable as a 10 it seems but can play either wing, much like Harrison.

I think a strict 6 makes a lot of sense.
 
  • Like
Reactions: cardinal511
Don’t forget that Harrison can also play in the middle. Rotating him into the midfield occasionally will also allow an opening for a substitute winger (Lewis?) to get on the field. Vieira last year did say he sees the middle as Harrison’s future.
 
Don’t forget that Harrison can also play in the middle. Rotating him into the midfield occasionally will also allow an opening for a substitute winger (Lewis?) to get on the field. Vieira last year did say he sees the middle as Harrison’s future.
Was just about to post this. We totally neglected to count him as a CAM guy.

I think that still leaves us needing a B2B, as Harrison’s defensive abilities as demonstrated to this point are not up to what you would like in an 8. Work-rate would be fine, mind. But I don’t think he’s shown enough bite for a real 8.
 
We can buy down Medina's transfer fee with TAM (I don't think there's a limit for TAM on fees) for those wondering if it's possible.
I think that could be an option. In order to do this we would have to amortize his transfer fee across the 4 years of his contract and then buy it down. Depends on what his salary is.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Fake Jew
When they drafted Harrison they viewed him as their long term #10. The fact that they signed Maxi and Medina in back to back years tells you all you need to know about the development of Jack as a 10
 
In terms of TAM players:

CM
-We definitely need another CM who is at a similar level as Ring, Herrera. We need to have a good squad and the options to rotate, last season Pirlo, TMac played far too many minutes. This allows us to not be overly reliant on our midfield 3 that are often not all available.

Winger
-As well as this we could do with another Winger, looking for someone who is better than Lewis/Wallace. Ideally someone who could play as Striker as well. Signing Ola Kamara would be stupid to say the least considering in the 2 years PV has been manager and when he managed the MCFC EDS he has hardly ever played a 2 striker system. The amount of TAM, GAM we would need to sign him would just not be worth it.

-Our style of play just doesn't work with 4-4-2, maybe if we set up like Barca do with a diamond midfield but we have Harrison and just signed a DP winger so I see this as unlikely, also considering PV has spent the last 2 seasons getting us some actual wingers with pace who are starting quality which he didn't have when he took over.

CB
-On top of this even if Chanot stays we need another CB who is starting quality. Considering Chanot's injury record this is really important.

In terms of non TAM players:

ST
-Obviously we don't have a recognised backup striker so having someone who could come on for Villa late on in matches or come on to partner him would be very useful. Probably looking at a young player who is relatively unproven.

CM/CDM
-Basically looking for a Lopez replacement, maybe use our first round draft pick on this player. We do however have Awuah and Sands but we lost Pirlo, Lopez and Stertzer so we probably need another depth player in this position.
-Someone young, low salary, good enough ability on the ball to play in a possession based system.

CB
-4th choice CB who would play around 5 games, could be a high draft pick(maybe we trade up). Perhaps could go for an experienced player if our TAM CB is young.

That would leave us with 26 players.

ST(2): Villa, non-TAM ST
W(5): Harrison, Medina, TAM W, Wallace, Lewis
CAM(2): Moralez, McNamara
CM/CDM(6): Ring, Herrera, TAM CM, Sands, Awuah, non-TAM CM
CB(4): Callens, Chanot, TAM CB, non-TAM CB
RB(2): Tinnerholm, Abdul-Salaam
LB(2): Matarrita, Sweat
GK (3): Johnson, Stuver, Rawls

Obviously some players can play different positions, having a TAM winger would mean we can rotate them with Harrison, Medina and Moralez for 3 spots and not have a significant drop off in terms of quality.

We would have good enough depth that we can rotate without causing the team to become considerably worse e.g. TMac, RJ Allen etc playing last season.

To be honest, I disagree about using TAM for a backup striker. Villa is what, 35? Can we really expect him to play 34 games? I think you sign a TAM striker for the express purpose of resting Villa. He should be rotated out when there's a double-game week, or three games in eight days. My goal is to get Villa to 25 games, and we can do that without negatively impacting the squad if we sign a really good backup. Ola as his understudy -- and as someone to bring on when we're chasing a goal -- would be interesting.
 
To be honest, I disagree about using TAM for a backup striker. Villa is what, 35? Can we really expect him to play 34 games? I think you sign a TAM striker for the express purpose of resting Villa. He should be rotated out when there's a double-game week, or three games in eight days. My goal is to get Villa to 25 games, and we can do that without negatively impacting the squad if we sign a really good backup. Ola as his understudy -- and as someone to bring on when we're chasing a goal -- would be interesting.
Without knowing how much TAM we have because mls it's hard to say, if we had the money available after signing TAM players in the other positions I said about then sure.

However I think those other positions are more important as the TAM players there would be playing more minutes and would have a realistic chance of being in our best 11 which a striker ultimately wouldn't be.

That's why I thought a TAM winger who can play as a ST would be ideal as they could play up front if we are resting Villa and then have Medina and Harrison playing as wingers.

I don't see how signing Kamara would make sense as one of our most expensive players outside of the DPs would only be starting 10 games at the most.
 
What about TPFKAU starting? Lopez? Too many times, even if only once.

You just hand points away when you send out shit like that.

I didn’t look at how much those guys started because some of Mac’s starts were at LW.

I just think it’s not worth paying $750K to bring in a guy who is going to start in 4 games. Especially if that means we can’t sign a top-level guy at CB or striker.

To be clear, I think we need another top-level CM added to the roster in addition to our current 3. The question is whether this guy, as a defensive mid, is it. I think it’s okay. Both Herrera and Ring can play a box-to-box role, and so you’d need both of those guys to be out to be in a pickle.
 
Last edited:
I don't see the Khedira difference in MLS. I can't fathom he provides much bigger of a difference in MLS than Ring for instance. It's just a different league than Europe

I don't think Kamara would come here. Makes no sense. But that's the quality of Forward I hope they are looking for. He's a guy that starts on half of MLS teams. And he's a scorer. He's not a Shelton or Wallace every now and then type. He's a scorer.
 
I didn’t look at how much those guys started because some of Mac’s starts were at LW.

I just think it’s not worth paying $750K to bring in a guy who is going to start in 4 games. Especially if that means we can’t sign a top-level guy at CB or striker.

To be clear, I think we need another top-level CM added to the roster in addition to our current 3. The question is whether this guy, as a defensive mid, is it. I think it’s okay. Both Herrera and Ring can play a box-to-box role, and so you’d need both of those guys to be out to be in a pickle.
Pirlo's starts and minutes have to be factored in as well.

Mikey Lopez - 600+ minutes at CM
Pirlo - nearly 1100 minutes at CM
T-Mac played 1500+ in total across all positions and made 11 out of 19 starts at CM.

If you aggregate those minutes you probably get around 2600-2700 minutes which is about what Maxi and Ring both played this season for us and they both probably could have used more rest.
 
Pirlo's starts and minutes have to be factored in as well.

Mikey Lopez - 600+ minutes at CM
Pirlo - nearly 1100 minutes at CM
T-Mac played 1500+ in total across all positions and made 11 out of 19 starts at CM.

If you aggregate those minutes you probably get around 2600-2700 minutes which is about what Maxi and Ring both played this season for us and they both probably could have used more rest.
When TMac was supposedly playing LW his position on the field remarkably resembled a left-side holding midfielder directing traffic.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Kjbert