11 of 28 spots can be protected - that's only 39% of the team. Of those 11, nobody would ever question not keeping a DP/TAM player, so that is Villa, Pirlo, Chanot, Mix, Johnson (technically TAM after it being used for his acquisition). That leaves 6 of 28. Mataritta is a valuable commodity that will be transferred next year for a profit, so that then leaves 5of28 = 18%. There were really only 5 spots that the Front Office had to decide, and from those they were definitely choosing Cap Friendly producers in TMac & Khiry & RJ, and the workhorse CB Brillant. That left one spot out of 11. As has been debated on the Forums, there were pros/cons to choosing Lopez, mainly because of his Cap value and he served a particular role of DMid. It's really no slight to the other guys that weren't picked - there were probably pros to keeping all of them since they all were under contract, most getting options exercised, and that action alone means that the team values their service - they just didn't have more than 1 spot to logically play with.