2015 Offseason Megathread

Status
Not open for further replies.
I'd say no. Allen is great at man-marking and he has some serious speed (which would be wasted in the middle as a defense-first cog), but I'm not sure he has the tactical awareness to play zone in the middle and snuff out attacks. Then again, I've never seen him placed in that situation so there's a chance he could be a total savant.
He also fouls alot too. Middle of the field is a dangerous area to give up free kicks.
 
So, it sounds like a lot of the team will be back in training tomorrow. Shouldn't we know then who is part of the team and who isn't? I pray.
 
Alvarez opens an international slot. Internationals that matter cost more
Than 60k. For this move to be meaningful, we need a hefty American salary to be moved
 
4-3-3 is likely coming to NYCFC with Vieira. How would you play it?

Does Vieria use a false 9? I posted this a few pages back as my idea for the best use of Poku:

NYCFC-formation-tactics.png


That FA RW spot can probably be filled with a EDS loanee. Maybe another FB too, but I'd prefer the CB and DM spots filled by someone who would be here longer than a year.

Mix would get plenty of playing time in this formation, even though he's not a first-choice starter. He backs up both Lampard (injury risk) and Pirlo (Euros), and can be used frequently as a substitute and spot starter in Cup matches or just to give the older guys rest. Not to mention, he would step in full time as a replacement after this season.
 
4-3-3 is likely coming to NYCFC with Vieira. How would you play it?
Based on current roster only (Angelino and Facey are included) - no what-if players:

Villa Mullins Taylor

Lampard Mix

Pirlo

Angelino - Facey - Mena - Allen

Johansen

I'm not smart enough to figure out how to get Poku on the field. All bets off with new players coming in.
 
FA RW - This should be Khiry. This is where Vieira needs to show chops and gusto. I will be keying in on his development of Poku, Shelton and Mix.

FA DM - EDS loan for sure. Need young capable legs there.

FA CB - Do we dare ask for (I can't even believe I'm typing this shit...) Lord Kwame here? He's 28 but he SHOULD be a better baller. Can Vieira bring it out?

Iraola - Still think he was a poor buy. I'd open this position up to someone else.
 
FA RW - This should be Khiry. This is where Vieira needs to show chops and gusto. I will be keying in on his development of Poku, Shelton and Mix.

Agreed, but depth is always good. Not picking on you, but people around here always seem content to have just one player for each spot. Villa is an injury risk, it would be nice to have at least 3 capable starting winger types.

FA DM - EDS loan for sure. Need young capable legs there.

I'd love a long term solution here.

FA CB - Do we dare ask for (I can't even believe I'm typing this shit...) Lord Kwame here? He's 28 but he SHOULD be a better baller. Can Vieira bring it out?

You're insane.

Iraola - Still think he was a poor buy. I'd open this position up to someone else.

Word is he played injured. I agree though that I want a new permanent LB, and to give Iraola a second chance with Allen waiting in the wings if he continues to flounder.
 
If it is 4-3-3, I want

FA/Loan LW---------------------Villa-------------------Shelton
----------------------------Poku----------------------------
-----------------------Mix----------Pirlo--------------------------
------FA/ Loan LB---Mena-----Hernandez/FA--------Iraola
----------------------------Johansen--------------------------

Cycle the midfield. Lampard would still play regularly
 
when do roster changes happen the most in MLS ? i expect nothing to happen until the season is over no? since teams are still in playoffs or on break.
 
Villa-------------------------Poku------------------Shelton
----------------------------Lampard----------------------------
-----------------------Mix----------Pirlo--------------------------
------FA/ Loan LB---Mena-----Hernandez/FA--------Iraola
----------------------------Johansen--------------------------



I think we have to start Lampard. Play Poku at CF. Alot of people have Allen at LB but he needs a left foot as good as his right for that to happen.
 
Villa-------------------------Poku------------------Shelton
----------------------------Lampard----------------------------
-----------------------Mix----------Pirlo--------------------------
------FA/ Loan LB---Mena-----Hernandez/FA--------Iraola
----------------------------Johansen--------------------------



I think we have to start Lampard. Play Poku at CF. Alot of people have Allen at LB but he needs a left foot as good as his right for that to happen.

Agreed on Allen. I like him, but I think it's true he's better on the right side. And probably best as a backup.

As for Poku, I really don't think he's a true CF. He doesn't play with his back to the goal, and doesn't keep the line. He's best out of a dribble. I think he's a CAM or, if he plays as a striker, a False 9 that drops deep to receive the ball (and then turn and dribble) or draw the centerbacks out to create running lanes for Villa and the other winger.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top