Minnesota Challenge (Aug 20) - vote!

[joe]

We basically have a whole new team, who do you think will be a factor Sunday? I figure Bakrar is locked in, but let me know if I missed anyone.

Maxi Moralez
A. Not in the 18
B. In the 18, doesn't play
C. Plays fewer than 5 minutes
D. Plays fewer than 20 minutes
E. Halftime sub
F. Starts

Alonso Martinez
A. Not in the 18
B. In the 18, doesn't play
C. Plays fewer than 5 minutes
D. Plays fewer than 20 minutes
E. Halftime sub
F. Starts

Julian Fernandez
A. Not in the 18
B. In the 18, doesn't play
C. Plays fewer than 5 minutes
D. Plays fewer than 20 minutes
E. Halftime sub
F. Starts

Birk Risa
A. Not in the 18
B. In the 18, doesn't play
C. Plays fewer than 5 minutes
D. Plays fewer than 20 minutes
E. Halftime sub
F. Starts

Andres Perea
A. Not in the 18
B. In the 18, doesn't play
C. Plays fewer than 5 minutes
D. Plays fewer than 20 minutes
E. Halftime sub
F. Starts

 

[mgarbowski]

If I believe someone will get 21-45 minutes (ie is subbed on after the half but before '70) I should pick E Halftime sub, correct?

 

[joe]

If I believe someone will get 21-45 minutes (ie is subbed on after the half but before '70) I should pick E Halftime sub, correct?

Yes, sounds good. I was trying to find a reasonable balance of categories but can tweak if there's a need.

 

[joe]

Maxi Moralez
D. Plays fewer than 20 minutes


Alonso Martinez
E. Halftime sub


Julian Fernandez
C. Plays fewer than 5 minutes


Birk Risa
D. Plays fewer than 20 minutes

Andres Perea
BABY PARKS EDIT: E. Halftime sub

 

[Shwafta]

Maxi: D - <20
Alonso: C <5
Julian: E
Birk: E
Perea: A

 

[mgarbowski]

Yes, sounds good. I was trying to find a reasonable balance of categories but can tweak if there's a need.

I don't think you need a new category with that confirmation.

 

[Gotham Gator]

I've been planning a Gotham-style Starting XI for this one. First time in a while it would be the least bit interesting.

Maxi: D
Alonso: D
Julian: D
Birk: F
Perea: C

This is a good exercise. It's making me go back and figure out who all these guys actually are.

 

[mgarbowski]

Maxi - E
Martinez - F
Fernandez - A
Risa - D
Perea - B

 

[LionNYC]

Can I move this to the match thread instead?

 

[joe]

Can I move this to the match thread instead?

Nope!

 

[LionNYC]

Nope!

This thread will be dead by prematch on Sunday. And then what, it just sits here taking up space on the main page seeing all the thread. I'm leaning into LionMOD space...

 

[joe]

Same as the guess the attendance and match results. If it’s merged into the game thread it’ll get buried and I won’t be able to compute the results

 

[mgarbowski]

Would it be enough to keep the thread separate until a couple of says after the game so joe has a chance to find the entries and do the tally and then fold it in too the game thread? I agree it will help a lot to keep it separate at least that long. I then do not much care whether it is kept separate or folded in after that.

 

[Seth]

Would it be enough to keep the thread separate until a couple of says after the game so joe has a chance to find the entries and do the tally and then fold it in too the game thread? I agree it will help a lot to keep it separate at least that long. I then do not much care whether it is kept separate or folded in after that.

You know, it's taking all my self-control to not make a new poll thread on if and when we should merge this in. I'm tryin' to behave, honest!

 

[JCMore]

Maxi Moralez
F. Starts

Alonso Martinez
A. Not in the 18


Julian Fernandez
B. In the 18, doesn't play

Birk Risa
A. Not in the 18

Andres Perea
D. Half time sub

Edit: changed Andres due to the Keaton parks news

 

[LionNYC]

Would it be enough to keep the thread separate until a couple of says after the game so joe has a chance to find the entries and do the tally and then fold it in too the game thread? I agree it will help a lot to keep it separate at least that long. I then do not much care whether it is kept separate or folded in after that.

I would agree to that if joe does!

 

[joe]

I would agree to that if joe does!

I still think it's over-moderating against a problem we don't have. I will be less annoyed if it's moved after I post the results next week, but for me it merits its own thread.

 

[joe]

Open until lineups are announced!

 

[Shwafta]

Maxi: D - <20
Alonso: C <5
Julian: E
Birk: E
Perea: A

Lol I was so very extremely wrong

 

[joe]

Maxi Moralez
F. Starts

Alonso Martinez
A. Not in the 18


Julian Fernandez
B. In the 18, doesn't play

Birk Risa
A. Not in the 18

Andres Perea
D. Half time sub

Edit: changed Andres due to the Keaton parks news

Half time sub was technically E, but I'm going to assume intent here and call JC the winner with two correct answers, Maxi and Perea. I made the same change to Perea when I heard the news.

Gotham wins a three way tie for second based on differential.

Shoutout to Mark, whose "half time sub" clarification proved relevant, both Fernandez and Perea ended up in that bucket

I'm glad to have been wrong about Risa, who I wanted to start but didn't think they would.

Thanks all for playing. JCMore I'll buy you a beer if we ever meet