I only have the original bar scarf. Of all of them the summer scarf is my favorite (dark blue with cleft crest).I like it ok, but I haven't found the one yet. Options are limited -- currently for sale on nycfc.com are the one above and the "NYCFC Adidas Sublimated Draft Scarf" in addition to a few that are no longer for sale/never were for sale:
View attachment 1068
The striped scarf is the one that Villa & Voldemort used in their initial NYCFC photos, I think. And then there's another that Mix had today:
View attachment 1069
Man Adidas really is sucking it big time with the merch. The scarves available on the site are awful. Was the blue and white striped one above ever for sale? That's the one I want.