I agree with you.
For those who are interested, these are the "big" NYRB Academy names. All of these kids have already played at U-20 with the USMNT. Three of them are from New York State. I don't know the rules about which team gets whom moving forward...
Santiago Castano - Queens, NY - Goalkeeper
Evan Louro - Ridgefield, NY - Goalkeeper
Matt Miazga - Clifton, NJ - Defender
Andrew Lombard - Montclair, NJ - Defender
Christopher Lema - Ridgefield, NJ - Midfielder
Alex Muyl - Georgetown, NY - Midfielder
Adam Najem - Clifton, NJ - Midfielder
Juan Sanchez - Ossining, NY - Striker