I do feel like we might slip behind Philly and the Supporters' Shield leaders considering we only have two real home games left for the rest of the season. Unless we absolutely kill it in the road games, we're probably going to be dropping a few points here and there considering the tough schedule remaining.
The only saving grace is that we do not have a lot of games left against good teams. Road against Montreal and home to Red Bulls might be our toughest remaining games.
Away Montreal (3rd)
Away Columbus (6th)
Away Inter Miami (11th)
Home Charlotte (RBA) (8th)
Away Chicago (9th)
Away Orlando (5th)
Home D.C. United (RBA) (Last)
Away New England (10th)
Home FC Cincinnati (Citi Field) (7th)
Away Charlotte (8th)
Home New Jersey (Yankee Stadium) (4th)
Home Orlando (RBA) (5th)
Away Atlanta (12th)
So only 5 of last 13 games against teams in playoff position; two of those on the road. Five games remaining against teams in 9th, 10th, 11th, 12th, and 14th place in the East.
We do have to do well on the road. In fact, if we don't get at least, say, 4-7 points in the next 3 road games there is a chance we will learn that the odds of the Shield or first place are very dim if the Union and at least one of LAFC and Austin do well. Even 4 might not be enough if a couple of them get 7 or 9, which is not inconceivable. Unfortunately, even 7-9 points for NYCFC probably does not make us extreme favorites on the upside. It might just keep pace.
The last 5 games of our schedule is a killer. I take your point about the table placement of our opponents, but look at the H/A records of those last 5 opponents:
Our Home Games
Red Bulls are the third best Away team in the league.
Cincinnati has a result in 7 of 11 road games.
Orlando earned a result in 9 of 11 road games.
Any result for these 3 teams means points dropped at home for NYCFC.
Our Away Games
Charlotte and Atlanta are low on the table because they both suck on the road, with a combined 10 points in 20 road games. We play them at their homes, where Charlotte gets 2.1 PPG and Atlanta is a respectable 1.73. Best we can hope is Atlanta is out of contention on Decision Day and they mail it in.
Right now, NYC has 1.56 PPG Away, which is better than any previous NYCFC full season Away PPG. But it's not enough. This year LAFC has 1.90 PPG Away, Austin is 1.92, and the Union 1.73. We have to kill it to keep up.