Savile Rogue Scarf Designs Vote

[Tiger Jones]

Just heard back from Savile Rogue. They've looked at our designs and have configured a few choices for us to decide on. I've started a new thread for a poll but these threads should eventually be merged by one of the mods. Here is the link.

 

[Nicholas Constantino]

Voting C. Like all of them though, except the first one looks like it has a faded Dutch flag pattern on it.

 

[CTNYCFC]

I'd love D if it lacked navy. The ends are my favorite part, but I don't like the pattern break. In any case, great work! If anything swayed me to invest this kind of cash in a scarf, these designs would be it.

 

[LostAnvil]

Voting C. Like all of them though, except the first one looks like it has a faded Dutch flag pattern on it.

A has the pattern of the NYC Flag

 

[Nicholas Constantino]

A has the pattern of the NYC Flag

Didn't know that was a real thing. Really cool then!

 

[Tiger Jones]

We've put together a few other designs. Does anyone like these more than the four I originally showed? Any other input?



I happen to like these a lot more as the orange is only a highlight and doesn't overpower the look and feel of it. Thoughts?

 

[Tom in Fairfield CT]

J is the best of the bunch

 

[Tiger Jones]

J is the best of the bunch

I think you may be right. I keep flipping back and worth. I can't decide. I like G & I a lot too. I don't know.

 

[roxfontaine]

Hmm... I like letter I out of this bunch.

 

[Tom in Fairfield CT]

I don't like the navy as the primary color since that is not really used much on the kits

 

[Tiger Jones]

I don't like the navy as the primary color since that is not really used much on the kits

I thought so as well but it's actually the primary color in the logo and most people have said they would prefer navy blue to be the base.

 

[Tiger Jones]

Maybe not primary but it pops more on it anyway...

 

[Ahab_Flanders]

Not a big fan of H, but all three of the others would be alright by me.

 

[thesauerchise]

I like J the best

 

[lostblue]

I still like C best because it's simple, NYCFC colors. The designs with 4 colors feel too busy.

 

[Drainyoo]

We've put together a few other designs. Does anyone like these more than the four I originally showed? Any other input?

View attachment 1132

I happen to like these a lot more as the orange is only a highlight and doesn't overpower the look and feel of it. Thoughts?

These are a lot better. I or J. Less Orange is better and so is more Navy, which is the dominant color in the logo. I'd buy either one right away. If I had to pick one, definitely I.

 

[Tiger Jones]

Thanks for your input guys. I received the final designs this morning (which include a darker orange) so I will reconfigure the poll later today and we can get a final tally. Thanks again.

 

[Tiger Jones]

I know it's been a few days since any update. I'm just waiting for Savile Rogue to give me one more round of designs. In the meantime, here are the ones that are in the running with "I" seemingly getting the most attention through the forums, FB and other people I've spoken to. In the meantime, here's all the designs in the running. I will put a new poll up in the next couple of days. I'm not sold on the way orange is incorporated in these but I definitely want it included. Any ideas to make it less obtrusive?

 

[northernburbs]

I have no interest in buying a $100 scarf, but I would try to keep the white to a minimum. the other fibers that get on it make it look dirty

 

[Tiger Jones]

I have no interest in buying a $100 scarf, but I would try to keep the white to a minimum. the other fibers that get on it make it look dirty

I have a red and white one. It looks great and has held up for several years.