Toronto - Postmatch

JayH said:
Any word on Lewis' absence? Did he make the trip? Unless there was some news that I missed, it's not a good sign when now fresh eyes from a coach of Dome's caliber (who also is seemingly a fair and reasonable guy) has concerns about Lewis (whether it’s the lack of defensive awareness and/or otherwise).
Click to expand...

There's no place for him in the 18 with Castellanos here, quite frankly. Who of these players is he supposed to leap over on the depth chart?

David Villa
Ismael Tajouri-Shradi
Jesus Medina
Jo Inge Berget
Valentin Castellanos

Let's be honest -- all of those players deserve to be in the 18 more than Lewis does. That's not to say Lewis is a bad player -- he's not. But the fact he can't even crack the 18 is an indication of just how good our attacking options are.
 
Sloppy defense, bad goaltending, lazy passes, lucky result.

Thinking we may have played better if they didn't get a red.

Our LB issue is a glaring one that wasn't addressed. It will continue to bite us in the ass.
 
ZYanksRule said:
There's no place for him in the 18 with Castellanos here, quite frankly. Who of these players is he supposed to leap over on the depth chart?

David Villa
Ismael Tajouri-Shradi
Jesus Medina
Jo Inge Berget
Valentin Castellanos

Let's be honest -- all of those players deserve to be in the 18 more than Lewis does. That's not to say Lewis is a bad player -- he's not. But the fact he can't even crack the 18 is an indication of just how good our attacking options are.
Click to expand...
I think a team should always have 3 attacking subs on the bench. Wallace doesn’t count as one if his last 18months are an indication. He should be dropped for Lewis. Seriously, after we made the Berget sub, I knew we had no other sparkplug options and had figured a draw was best we’d get because Isi was not doing much of anything outside of his amazing goals - but if Lewis was on the bench we’d at least have had an option for one more change.

So to circle back, the bench should have: 1GK, 2 Defenders (both inside/outside), one midfielder, and 3 forwards. In a pinch, a forward can double as a midfielder if injuries require it, or a starter (Isa, Medina) can be dropped back to full in. Having both TMac and Wallace on the bench was duplicating ineffectiveness.
 
Ulrich said:
I think a team should always have 3 attacking subs on the bench. Wallace doesn’t count as one if his last 18months are an indication. He should be dropped for Lewis. Seriously, after we made the Berget sub, I knew we had no other sparkplug options and had figured a draw was best we’d get because Isi was not doing much of anything outside of his amazing goals - but if Lewis was on the bench we’d at least have had an option for one more change.

So to circle back, the bench should have: 1GK, 2 Defenders (both inside/outside), one midfielder, and 3 forwards. In a pinch, a forward can double as a midfielder if injuries require it, or a starter (Isa, Medina) can be dropped back to full in. Having both TMac and Wallace on the bench was duplicating ineffectiveness.
Click to expand...

I think in your example, you're right that Lewis would deserve to be in the 18. It seems to me that we've normally had 2 D, 2 M, and 2 F's on the bench for most games. If we have a third forward on the bench, then yes Lewis deserves that spot.
 
ZYanksRule said:
There's no place for him in the 18 with Castellanos here, quite frankly. Who of these players is he supposed to leap over on the depth chart?

David Villa
Ismael Tajouri-Shradi
Jesus Medina
Jo Inge Berget
Valentin Castellanos

Let's be honest -- all of those players deserve to be in the 18 more than Lewis does. That's not to say Lewis is a bad player -- he's not. But the fact he can't even crack the 18 is an indication of just how good our attacking options are.
Click to expand...
Lewis is better then Castellanos. No way you can say Castellanos is better then Lewis at all.
 
Ulrich said:
I think a team should always have 3 attacking subs on the bench. Wallace doesn’t count as one if his last 18months are an indication. He should be dropped for Lewis. Seriously, after we made the Berget sub, I knew we had no other sparkplug options and had figured a draw was best we’d get because Isi was not doing much of anything outside of his amazing goals - but if Lewis was on the bench we’d at least have had an option for one more change.

So to circle back, the bench should have: 1GK, 2 Defenders (both inside/outside), one midfielder, and 3 forwards. In a pinch, a forward can double as a midfielder if injuries require it, or a starter (Isa, Medina) can be dropped back to full in. Having both TMac and Wallace on the bench was duplicating ineffectiveness.
Click to expand...
I don't see any argument for having TMac in the 18. I can see an argument for Wallace, because he can do some things that others can't (note, I'm not calling him to be subbed in, or to start, just that he can play defense). I could see Wallace as a good sub to bring on when trying to protect a lead, but definitely not an option when needing a goal.
 
hank said:
Lewis is better then Castellanos. No way you can say Castellanos is better then Lewis at all.
Click to expand...

Lewis is a nice player, but it's pretty clear he's not going to be a main part of this team's offense. He's a better version of Shelton. A nice player, a role player, a guy that doesn't play a complete enough game to warrant more than a bit part.

I'll grant you that the jury is still out on Castellanos, but he's shown himself to be a pretty smart player so far, and he's going to be a much bigger part of these last four months than Lewis will if everyone is healthy.
 
ZYanksRule said:
Lewis is a nice player, but it's pretty clear he's not going to be a main part of this team's offense. He's a better version of Shelton. A nice player, a role player, a guy that doesn't play a complete enough game to warrant more than a bit part.

I'll grant you that the jury is still out on Castellanos, but he's shown himself to be a pretty smart player so far, and he's going to be a much bigger part of these last four months than Lewis will if everyone is healthy.
Click to expand...
That’s a pretty bad hot take. Lewis is light years better than Shelton as his G/A per 90 shows. He’s has singlehandedly saved points for the team. Is he fantastic in defense - nope, not really, but that is a far cry from saying he’s a better version of Shelton.
 
Ulrich said:
That’s a pretty bad hot take. Lewis is light years better than Shelton as his G/A per 90 shows. He’s has singlehandedly saved points for the team. Is he fantastic in defense - nope, not really, but that is a far cry from saying he’s a better version of Shelton.
Click to expand...

Yes, I did say he's better than Shelton, but in terms of his long-term prospects, he's nowhere near the rest of the depth chart. I think that was kind of the comparison I was trying to make. He's the kind of guy who's probably not getting a 2nd contract here.
 
ZYanksRule said:
Yes, I did say he's better than Shelton, but in terms of his long-term prospects, he's nowhere near the rest of the depth chart. I think that was kind of the comparison I was trying to make. He's the kind of guy who's probably not getting a 2nd contract here.
Click to expand...
He’s fringe NT talent. Made the U20 with no prior association to the feeder setup.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Similar threads

Shwafta
NYCFC Survivor 5 Winner!
Replies
0
Views
190
Shwafta
Shwafta
Davo15
Other Leagues 22-23
2
Replies
33
Views
4,609
Martin Hare
M
Shwafta
  • Sticky
NYCFC Survivor [2022 Edition] General Discussion
Replies
10
Views
2,171
mgarbowski
mgarbowski
adam
All time “homegrown” team
Replies
9
Views
1,826
goodbyetaty
G
mgarbowski
Rangers/Knicks Flex Bank?
Replies
8
Views
3,384
mgarbowski
mgarbowski
Back
Top