What exactly were they practicing against to simulate a dragon flying? Firing giant bolts at a raven? No amount of practice would have prepared them to take the flying dragon out with the first and second shot. Those were kill shots from a guy sitting in a bucket seat being assisted by multiple sailors rotating/elevating the scorpion, and acting in unison to be able to lead a flying target at distance; a team of five won’t get that right.If the dragons are that high in the sky I'm sure they could angle the shots over the ridge that was blocking the ships. They had some time to practice with Dany and the Northerners focused on the Night King.
Who says the ships were anchored? They turn the corner and there are numerous ships sailing with decent speed.
Numerous ships have the scorpion gun attached to the front of it, presumably 8-10 ships have the scorpion at the front, maybe even more.
True, but if you notice during the scene of Tyrion running around the ship there are numerous bolts flying by presumably hitting numerous other ships, as well as different heights/parts of the ship Tyrion is on. First shot they had some time to line up, the later shots are just lock and load.
These scorpions/bolts are designed to pierce full grown dragon skulls, they aren't being fired at low speeds.
View attachment 9766
I'm not doing this as a means to fight against your points, but just provide counterpoints that the actions weren't totally fantastical and do have reasonability to them.
If the dragons are that high, then sure, the Iron Born could shoot over BUT then it’d be super easy for the dragons/Danearys to have seen the ships sailing with white water trails behind them. Works both ways.
The hit rates were non-stop, and a weapon that big, firing bolts that large and powerful will require a huge amount of kinetic energy (via the tensioned bow/string) so the time to lock the mechanism back in a firing position is more complicated and time consuming than simply drawing a bow string back. Even with 8-10 boats at the front firing a volley, it’d have been a dead period between that and the next, and yet there wasn’t one.
Last edited: