General MLS Discussion

Rodolfo Borrell is a Man City assistant who was linked to us as a potential when Vieira left (and maybe again when Torrent quit, though I'm not certain. He now is possibly going to take the DC United job.

 
Rodolfo Borrell is a Man City assistant who was linked to us as a potential when Vieira left (and maybe again when Torrent quit, though I'm not certain. He now is possibly going to take the DC United job.


MLS is reporting DC will hire a US based coach.... rumors abound!

 
  • Like
Reactions: mgarbowski
Stephen Goff says the leading candidate in DC is Chris Armas.
Makes me sad how little ambition that club has especially with that shiny new stadium.
Atlantic Cup against New Jersey gonna be extra spicy now tho
 
Montreal Impact -> Montreal FC....

should have kept the impact imho... generic names, here we come.
 
Montreal Impact -> Montreal FC....

should have kept the impact imho... generic names, here we come.
I cannot find this news. They're still being called the Impact on the MLS and team websites, and I don't see an announcement of a coming change. I hope they keep the name. The only good thing about FC names is they're not "United."
 
  • Like
Reactions: Shwafta
I cannot find this news. They're still being called the Impact on the MLS and team websites, and I don't see an announcement of a coming change. I hope they keep the name. The only good thing about FC names is they're not "United."

 
Montreal Impact -> Montreal FC....

should have kept the impact imho... generic names, here we come.

I'm in the minority (or silent majority?) that doesn't mind generic names. I was a baseball guy for a long while and romanticized the days when teams would officially be called the Brooklyn Baseball Club and sportswriters would run with nicknames that fit the state of the club -- e.g., the Grays, Bridegrooms, and eventually Dodgers.

Would like to see more of that in MLS, and I see generic names as a canvas for it.
 
I'm in the minority (or silent majority?) that doesn't mind generic names. I was a baseball guy for a long while and romanticized the days when teams would officially be called the Brooklyn Baseball Club and sportswriters would run with nicknames that fit the state of the club -- e.g., the Grays, Bridegrooms, and eventually Dodgers.

Would like to see more of that in MLS, and I see generic names as a canvas for it.
That would be great in theory, but I don't think that there are many, if any, sportswriters that have the kind of creativity and dedication to each individual MLS team to come up with those kind of nicknames. Would we be called the Pigeons if that were the case?

Count me as someone who's disappointed that MLS moved toward generic names. I liked the original names and thought it gave MLS an American flair.
 
I'm in the minority (or silent majority?) that doesn't mind generic names. I was a baseball guy for a long while and romanticized the days when teams would officially be called the Brooklyn Baseball Club and sportswriters would run with nicknames that fit the state of the club -- e.g., the Grays, Bridegrooms, and eventually Dodgers.

Would like to see more of that in MLS, and I see generic names as a canvas for it.
The problem with Montreal is they did this in the wrong order. They are already the Impact and that will stick as the informal nickname crowding out any real organic one. Secondly, the two language situation will hamper things as well, unless something like les bleus or some faux French name gets some traction.
 
The problem with Montreal is they did this in the wrong order. They are already the Impact and that will stick as the informal nickname crowding out any real organic one. Secondly, the two language situation will hamper things as well, unless something like les bleus or some faux French name gets some traction.


That's why I suggested Olympique for a francophone team. Of course you've got Marseille and Lyon most famously but I believe you have at least one more team possibly Nimes that has an Olympique after it somewhere.
 
MLS Announces 25 Greatest, Most Influential Players for 25th Anniversary


Can't help but wonder if Villa would have made list but for the recent scandal. OTOH, everyone on the list either won MLS Cup, or played minimum 7-8 years (and many did both).
 
MLS Announces 25 Greatest, Most Influential Players for 25th Anniversary


Can't help but wonder if Villa would have made list but for the recent scandal. OTOH, everyone on the list either won MLS Cup, or played minimum 7-8 years (and many did both).
Yeah it's tough to see which of the forwards Villa beats out.

Dempsey and Donovan are both US legends, Donovan is miles ahead in both G and A and Dempsey played far longer. I think you could argue about Giovinco, but the fact that TFC won MLS Cup with Gio and we didn't with Villa is enough to keep Villa out. Keane had more G and A than Villa and won 3 MLS Cups, while Josef Martinez has the single-season goal record and an MLS Cup. Jaime Moreno was an early MLS legend, over 100 goals and 100 assists, won the Cup multiple times with DC. Wondo's another MLS legend, not so much a US legend but as the #1 career goal-scorer he's gonna have a spot on the list.

I think the only debatable entry against Villa is BWP. Yes he has more goals and assists, but he also played twice as long as Villa in MLS and the difference isn't that much (BWP: 125 goals, 36 assists in 8 seasons. Villa: 80 goals, 26 assists in 4 seasons). NYRB has won Supporter's Shield but not MLS Cup, so he doesn't have the cup win advantage. Still, it's a really close debate and I wouldn't be surprised if the recent scandal did play into it.