New York City FC Unveil a Refreshed Visual Identity Ahead of Club's 10th Season Home Opener

Which Logo Do You Prefer?

  • Original Logo

    Votes: 5 26.3%
  • New Logo

    Votes: 14 73.7%

  • Total voters
    19
Question is will they replace it at the new stadium and what will it look like?

is that banner even there? i think they moved the location and replaced it. its on right field side now.
 
Question is will they replace it at the new stadium and what will it look like?

Personally, I wish we kept the small field dimensions and got an even smaller banner for the new stadium just as a big FU to all the R/MLS complainers. Since we are conforming on the field size we might as well get a big banner too.
 
I'm imagining some marketing company coming up with a cool new logo and presenting it with a dramatic 30-second video where parts of the old logo fall away as it slowly morphs into the new logo. Only at the 2-second mark of the video when the ring drops away NYCFC leadership was like pause it, you've done it, this is perfect!

I'm not complaining, I like our logo so minimal change is good with me but I always think it's funny to think about the amount of design iterations and meetings that likely went into such a minor change.
You reminded me of my favorite scene in Broadcast News where 2 consultants demo their fresh news theme music intro to the network exec.

 
Last edited:
  • Haha
Reactions: gbservis
Was going to say, that you're suggesting they effectively keep it as is.
Yes. I mean, I get it, updating the crest is common. But usually, it's something like what Arsenal did, going from an old and super busy design to something clean and completely new (and boy howdy, was there some howling about that at first -- it was a massive change).

If you're going to stay so close to the original design, why change at all? They clearly know we love our crest. Punching it up would have been easy: a darker blue on the interior disc, darker lettering in the ring, brighter orange. Keep the fonts the same. That's what the crest on my hat looks like. It's gorgeous. And they already have the monogram crest for an alternative.

The new one strikes me as very generic. Not bad by any means. Just not as good as what we already have.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Gene
Really nice writeup from Hudson River Blue on the original design, the update and the general world of crests in MLS. Makes the point that the Club commissioned a custom font, so it was only a matter of time before it hit the crest.

Good piece. And the new badge is fine. Seeing it on Facebook and other social media, it certainly pops more.

And if I have the "classic" badge on my hat or Jonathan Sanchez has it tattooed somewhere, that's fine too. Before too long, it will be the retro look, and everyone will be happy again.
 
Good piece. And the new badge is fine. Seeing it on Facebook and other social media, it certainly pops more.

And if I have the "classic" badge on my hat or Jonathan Sanchez has it tattooed somewhere, that's fine too. Before too long, it will be the retro look, and everyone will be happy again.

In a few years when we open the new stadium, if you are wearing apparel with the old logo on it, you'll be seen as a long-term fan of the team, not just someone who showed up for the new stadium. You'll be seen as someone who was with the team during the tough times when they had to play home games at many different stadiums, even on the other side of the country.
 
  • Like
Reactions: KevinJRogers
In a few years when we open the new stadium, if you are wearing apparel with the old logo on it, you'll be seen as a long-term fan of the team, not just someone who showed up for the new stadium. You'll be seen as someone who was with the team during the tough times when they had to play home games at many different stadiums, even on the other side of the country.
My no-consequence conspiracy theory is they delayed revealing the new badge until September even though the general redesign came in March, because of the 2024 kit. Its no-badge logo uses the old fonts and probably was well in the works by the time the design refresh was ready. They didn't want to release a new jersey and simultaneously render it dated, so the new badge reveal was held until now.
 
Last edited:
My no-consequence conspiracy theory is they delayed revealing the new badge until September even though the general redesign came in March, because of the 2024 kit. Its no-badge logo uses the old fonts and probably was well in the works by the time the design refresh was ready. They didn't want to release a new jersey and simultaneously render it dated, so the new badge reveal was held until now.
That badge that leaked back in March was the exact same as this one
 
That badge that leaked back in March was the exact same as this one
Not the exact same one. This was the one that was leaked.

Side note, doesn't it seem the NYC in the middle is just a little up than it should be? Like there's much more dark blue borders in the bottom that towards the top parts of the Y.

0.png
 
  • Like
Reactions: SoupInNYC
Not the exact same one. This was the one that was leaked.

Side note, doesn't it seem the NYC in the middle is just a little up than it should be? Like there's much more dark blue borders in the bottom that towards the top parts of the Y.

View attachment 13501

glad they got rid of the little squares between the words.

the NYC looks fine to me. they are centered based on the center of each letter. the blue around the top parts of the Y are just a consequence of ensuring the Y doesn't get lost. personally, it doesn't look like it's off center.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Shwafta
glad they got rid of the little squares between the words.

the NYC looks fine to me. they are centered based on the center of each letter. the blue around the top parts of the Y are just a consequence of ensuring the Y doesn't get lost. personally, it doesn't look like it's off center.
Looks like they originally were going to have 5 squares and opted to just go back to the pentagons lol
 
I know I’m knit picking, but normally when a club goes through a rebrand, it’s on the front page of mlssoccerdotcom. We are even mentioned. Obviously it’s a redesign and not a rebranding, but I feel like maybe it should be mentioned
 
I know I’m knit picking, but normally when a club goes through a rebrand, it’s on the front page of mlssoccerdotcom. We are even mentioned. Obviously it’s a redesign and not a rebranding, but I feel like maybe it should be mentioned
Because it’s not active yet. They just announced they’re going to rebrand next year. And even then the kit will still have the old badge.
 
Because it’s not active yet. They just announced they’re going to rebrand next year. And even then the kit will still have the old badge.
I don’t think that matters tbh. I feel in the past they have shown rebrands when they have been announced instead of when they began using the image