NYCFC in the Media Thread - 2026

Interesting article by Matty Doyle this afternoon over on the MLS site.


Bernardo Silva
Manchester City
Silva’s probably been the second-best midfielder of the past dozen years (behind Luka Modrić), most of which has been spent winning one title after another with Manchester City and a handful with Portugal.
He’s been a ball-moving, field-tilting genius out there, much more of a No. 8 than a No. 10 for both club and country. But in MLS, he’d play either as a free No. 8 in a 4-3-3 that tilts towards his side, with more playmaking responsibility than the other No. 8, or as a pure No. 10 who’d dish out one tap-in after another.
Silva is still just 31, but is out of contract this summer. Any MLS team that intends to sign him will likely have to fight off some top clubs from the "big five" leagues, as well as the likes of Fenerbahçe, Benfica and the usual crop from Saudi Arabia.
Best MLS fit: If you’re an NYCFC fan, you couldn’t ask for a better Maxi Moralez successor/replacement.
 
Interesting article by Matty Doyle this afternoon over on the MLS site.

Silva would be amazing here. Hard to see that happening though but I'd be ecstatic if it did.
 
Silva would be amazing here. Hard to see that happening though but I'd be ecstatic if it did.
It would certainly be worth the standard NYCFC 1 window wait as we scream over no new signings this winter.
 
With Craig Carton back on the WFAN, what are the chances we get more than one Marty Edelman interview to talk about the team and the new stadium. As Craig is his nephew I say there is one interview right after Etihad Parks tickets sale process goes through then current STH and right before they hit the waiting list. Edelman did appear on the show once after the stadium is announced.
 
With Craig Carton back on the WFAN, what are the chances we get more than one Marty Edelman interview to talk about the team and the new stadium. As Craig is his nephew I say there is one interview right after Etihad Parks tickets sale process goes through then current STH and right before they hit the waiting list. Edelman did appear on the show once after the stadium is announced.

I think we'll see a rush of media attention when the stadium is on the verge of opening, but not before that.
 
I think Bogert hit the bong when putting this together.


For those without a subscription:

19. NYCFC​

Total: 26.5 points​

This is the last year NYCFC scores just one point in the non-soccer category before moving to their new Queens home. Pascal Jansen has the team playing attractive, winning soccer, Nico Fernández Mercau is a best XI-caliber player, while Maxi Moralez is a warm blanket of familiarity, chance creation and lovable nonsense.

Now personally I really don't have too much of a problem with the ranking, because this team is totally different without Martinez.
But putting NJ, Minnesota, Chicago, Houston and Colorado ahead of us? GTFOH.
 
I think Bogert hit the bong when putting this together.


For those without a subscription:



Now personally I really don't have too much of a problem with the ranking, because this team is totally different without Martinez.
But putting NJ, Minnesota, Chicago, Houston and Colorado ahead of us? GTFOH.

I think Minnesota makes sense, the James situation is going to be fascinating to watch. Chicago scored the 2nd most and gave up the 5th most goals in the league last year. If I was a natural fan I'd much rather watch Chicago score and concede goals at an insane rate than the 1 goal a game dysfunction that has been NYCFCs offense the last 3 years.

It's hard to make a case for the other clubs you listed being ahead of us but I could see how neutrals find NYCFC hard to watch. We have a very strong defense so the opposition isn't going to score much. Combine that with our offense which consists of high possession but an inability to finish and do much of anything with it and you get some pretty boring soccer. Even a defensive focused, park the bus type team, like Minn was last year creates excitement on the break and set pieces.

I think all that could change with a new #9. Pascal was trying to get the team to break out and attack faster in a few of the preseason games. Maxi can't and doesn't want to play at that pace but Nico, Wolf and Ojeda looked very well suited to it. Nico has the perfect skill set to lead the charge from the CAM position. If they get a quality #9 that can play the same way, we could be in for a much more entertaining NYCFC attack.
 
Now personally I really don't have too much of a problem with the ranking, because this team is totally different without Martinez.
But putting NJ, Minnesota, Chicago, Houston and Colorado ahead of us? GTFOH.

Bogert has done this before. You have to realize that (1) we always get 1/5 on stadium atmosphere until next year finally, and (2) some of the categories are about weirdness and potential disaster and shiny new things. Just give us a stadium 4 instead of 1 (hopefully we get and deserve a 5), and we jump ahead of every team on your list except Chicago. Honestly I'm surprised Bogert doesn't grade NYCFC as a 0 on that category. As for Chicago. they seem to be a bit of a trendy pick this year. I'm not sure why but Bogert is not an outlier.
On the weirdness and disaster points, we are excessively boring. We have one of the most tightly controlled corporate personalities of any team in the league. We have no stars,* and no odd characters for better or worse. Most analysts put the team in the kind of good to pretty good level. Pascal is very good at what he does but a step down from both Ronny and even Nick as a character. Can you see Pascal singing a drunken bawdy song like Nick after the 2021 MLS Cup win? I can't. I like him but he's boring as a personality. He won't even wear an old undershirt to a video interview. Nearly naked push-ups, referee rants, and disquisitions about printers, are probably not happening.
On the more positive points, we have one player who scored double digit goals last year and he scored -- 11. As for shiny new things, we have no new players about whom a neutral is likely to say "I can't wait to see what he does!" I'm not even sure Sylla would have moved that needle much, though he probably would have raised our score a bit.

* Maxi? He deserved to be a bigger MLS star than he became, but he didn't, and he'll be 39 next week.
 
Back
Top