NYCFC Season Discussion 2025: Party Like It's 2023 (2024 If You're Lucky)

i think the thread is worth it even without the long analytical posts from Mark (which I like very much).
My point was kind of the opposite. I'm not planning to stop writing occasional analytical posts. I've already reduced the frequency considerably and I can't promise any specific intervals but they will still happen. But it seems that without my regular posts almost nobody thinks to post in this thread.

I just checked and there is exactly 1 post by someone other than me that was not posted within 48 hours after I wrote something here. It happens to be by you, on July 26 ( the most glorious and winning day in NYCFC history as it happens). With that one exception, there just no discussion here unless I initiate it. So I was thinking it might make sense to simply post in whatever thread is carrying the conversation at any given time.

It's certainly no burden to create this thread. I do like having my posts of this type collected, and it seems at least a couple others do as well. So maybe I'll just keep it going.
 
Melting The Simpsons GIF
 
My point was kind of the opposite. I'm not planning to stop writing occasional analytical posts. I've already reduced the frequency considerably and I can't promise any specific intervals but they will still happen. But it seems that without my regular posts almost nobody thinks to post in this thread.

I just checked and there is exactly 1 post by someone other than me that was not posted within 48 hours after I wrote something here. It happens to be by you, on July 26 ( the most glorious and winning day in NYCFC history as it happens). With that one exception, there just no discussion here unless I initiate it. So I was thinking it might make sense to simply post in whatever thread is carrying the conversation at any given time.

It's certainly no burden to create this thread. I do like having my posts of this type collected, and it seems at least a couple others do as well. So maybe I'll just keep it going.

I really enjoy this thread and your analytics—it’s nice to have a place where the discussion stays focused on the bigger picture. I’ll admit I have a bad habit of just clicking “new posts” and jumping into the latest active thread instead of finding the one that best fits my thoughts. I’ll try to be better about that.

I think the roster’s constant state of incompleteness over the past three years has pulled a lot of general performance discussions out of threads like this one and into the roster thread. Hopefully, this is only temporary, and at some point the roster stabilizes. Right now, it feels like we’re stuck in a perpetual holding pattern, unable to fully discuss the team's performance until the roster is complete. I was just thinking the other day how much more enjoyable it was when debates centered on formations, tactics, player availability, and coaching decisions, rather than this lingering cloud of an unfinished roster that’s been hanging over everything since Taty left.
 
Back
Top