How was the Bronx Ale House?
It was pretty good. We got there around 2pm from Staten Island. It was a bit of a trek and it's nowhere near the stadium so that deterred me. BUT, the food was great and the Third Rail IPA and Founder's Ales were $1 off and you received a raffle ticket which each beer for a chance to win NYCFC merch. My wife won a t-shirt so she was happy with that. It wasn't too crowded which was also nice.
In order to beat the crowds we took a cab from there which was simple enough but my driver took some backwards way and took us about 20 minutes to get to YS from the ale house. I would consider going there again but it's a little out of the way and not necessarily worth the trouble. If you're coming from the north I would definitely suggest it.