2019 Roster Discussion
- Thread starter NYCFC_Dan
- Start date
Having Sweat retire would be optimal. Especially since our genius FO killed the only reason to keep him around by giving him a fat contract. Bastard couldn’t be bothered to run back or cut out a cross when he was hungry to get a living wage. Now? AS IF, mufukkers.Having Sweat, Tinnerholm and Matarita play as wingbacks would suit their particular sets of talents.
We could. But they chewed up that political capital already with Dome and friends.
Last edited:
Yes, per TopDrawerSoccer, Haak committed to the University of Maryland
I think both Chanot and Ring make fantastic leaders.
is this the entry draft where teams can re negotiate with player? since im assuming dynamo is not paying that salary to him.
- Jul 14, 2014
- 795
- 955
- 143
- 37
Now the dynamo will win supporters shield and mls cup
https://www.mlssoccer.com/post/2018/12/20/warshaw-my-top-5-list-every-position-mls-2018
Not a single player listed in the top 5 of his position.
Not a single player listed in the top 5 of his position.
that's absurd. Ring feels like the greatest omission to me followed by Callens, and SJ.
Any list that doesn't have Maxi in it is absurd. Dude was clearly best XI in the league last season.
Maxi is our best and most important player but I can see a rationale for leaving any of our attacking players off the list based on how few goals we scored in the second half of the season. It also depends on how they categorize Maxi. I'd bet most of us recognize him as a box to box MF but most of the league probably assumes he's an attacking midfielder. It would be an easier case to advocate for him being above a bunch of the guys on the box to box list as opposed to the attacking midfielder list.
What a fucking idiot.
The fact that someone pays Bobby Warshaw to provide content and analysis is a black eye to American soccer.
Ring is the best DM in MLS. Callens is a Top 5 CB easily.
Maxi is a borderline Top 5 CAM. Johnson is a borderline Top 5 GK.
But the defensive midfielder conversation in MLS begins with Alex Ring. He’s in a tier all by himself.
Maxi is a borderline Top 5 CAM. Johnson is a borderline Top 5 GK.
But the defensive midfielder conversation in MLS begins with Alex Ring. He’s in a tier all by himself.
13 points in the final 13 games has had a major effect on perceptions. Flip our season so we start with that and end with 17 points in the final 7, and we're ecstatic, and MLS writers would be putting the team and its players on top of all the lists. From an individual player perspective, some at least would probably get more credit as an excellent player on a poor team. There's a certain romanticism to that. But when a team self-implodes the stink is pervasive.
TBF Maxi was an "honorable mention" for CAM.
I thought it was hilarious that Gressel made top 5 RB because he played a few games there.
I've learned only to pay attention to Warshaw when he's breaking down one specific play. Anything else feels pretty consistently bait-y.
I find about 10-20% of his written or spoken commentary to be solidly informative. The rest is a mix of clickbait, undisguised trolling, and ignorant conventional wisdom.
Similar threads
- Poll
- Poll
