Regarding Gudi, I think he was just fine, and that was all that team needed.
ASA has Tinnerholm (3 times), Ronald Matarrita (3 times), Malte Amundsen (once), RJ Allen (twice), and Jeb Brovsky (once) as having a better goals added for a season than Gudi's best year (2021 - Malte in 2021 had a G+ of 0.79 compared to Gudi's 0.26 while Gudi played more minutes).
Gudi's FK against Atlanta is absolutely why we remember him much more fondly and I think completely overrate his performance while he was here (not saying he was bad, he just wasn't close to the top level this team has had).
He really produced next to nothing except for the Atlanta game and then the playoff stretch.
In total, he had 2 goals and 3 assists during his 2 seasons at NYCFC. 2 of those assists were in the playoffs (off the bench) and the one goal against Atlanta.
ASA has Tinnerholm (3 times), Ronald Matarrita (3 times), Malte Amundsen (once), RJ Allen (twice), and Jeb Brovsky (once) as having a better goals added for a season than Gudi's best year (2021 - Malte in 2021 had a G+ of 0.79 compared to Gudi's 0.26 while Gudi played more minutes).
Gudi's FK against Atlanta is absolutely why we remember him much more fondly and I think completely overrate his performance while he was here (not saying he was bad, he just wasn't close to the top level this team has had).
He really produced next to nothing except for the Atlanta game and then the playoff stretch.
In total, he had 2 goals and 3 assists during his 2 seasons at NYCFC. 2 of those assists were in the playoffs (off the bench) and the one goal against Atlanta.
