2023 Roster and Transfer Discussion Thread

Which positions do you think need a new signing?

  • Goalkeeper

    Votes: 3 5.8%
  • Center back

    Votes: 20 38.5%
  • Left back

    Votes: 12 23.1%
  • Right back

    Votes: 17 32.7%
  • Defensive Midfielder

    Votes: 5 9.6%
  • Midfielder (standard)

    Votes: 12 23.1%
  • Attacking Midfielder

    Votes: 12 23.1%
  • Striker (forward)

    Votes: 48 92.3%
  • Left Winger

    Votes: 1 1.9%
  • Right Winger

    Votes: 1 1.9%
  • Other

    Votes: 0 0.0%

  • Total voters
    52
I'll be interested to see how we lineup with Sands on the pitch - there's a lot of coverage needed for Chanot -- do we go to a 3ATB until LCB is straightened away or are we using Sands in the MF?

Or now that he's busted his goal scoring cherry do we think he's our next #9?




(joking about the 9...)
 
NYCFC 2023 DEPTH CHART

Striker: Segal
Wing/Striker: Talles Magno, Thiago
Wing: Pereira, Jasson, Jimenez
Wing/CAM: Pellegrini
CAM: Carrizo
CM: Parks, Haak
CDM/CB: Sands, Morales
RB: Gray, Ilenič
LB: Cufre, O'Toole, Amundsen, McFarlane, Turnbull
CB: Chanot, Martins, Alfaro, Owusu, Benalcazar
GK: Barraza, Freese, Mizell
 
Maybe David Lee knew what he was doing all along.
It's funny, but I noticed how Keaton said "trust the process" after our first game. That's exactly what Edu and Arteta were saying a year ago when Arsenal were in a similar position after losing the opener to Brentford. Being a Gooner, it caught my eye immediately.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Kjbert and Higgs1
I'll be interested to see how we lineup with Sands on the pitch - there's a lot of coverage needed for Chanot -- do we go to a 3ATB until LCB is straightened away or are we using Sands in the MF?

Or now that he's busted his goal scoring cherry do we think he's our next #9?




(joking about the 9...)

cushing played 3ATB late in the season last year and it worked well for us. but i think his preferred formation is 4-3-3. that being said, he's shown that he can be and does want to be flexible in formations. having sands back will let him transition from 4-3-3 to 3-5-2 or 4-2-3-1 very easily. it's a huge boost in terms of flexibility.

i can't wait to see our boy shine again.
 
cushing played 3ATB late in the season last year and it worked well for us. but i think his preferred formation is 4-3-3. that being said, he's shown that he can be and does want to be flexible in formations. having sands back will let him transition from 4-3-3 to 3-5-2 or 4-2-3-1 very easily. it's a huge boost in terms of flexibility.

i can't wait to see our boy shine again.

I can see us doing what we did in 2021, which was a 4-2-3-1 with Sands falling back into a 3 ATB at times.
 
NYCFC 2023 DEPTH CHART

Striker: Segal
Wing/Striker: Talles Magno, Thiago
Wing: Pereira, Jasson, Jimenez
Wing/CAM: Pellegrini
CAM: Carrizo
CM: Parks, Haak
CDM/CB: Sands, Morales
RB: Gray, Ilenič
LB: Cufre, O'Toole, Amundsen, McFarlane, Turnbull
CB: Chanot, Martins, Alfaro, Owusu, Benalcazar
GK: Barraza, Freese, Mizell
This may be our squad for the next few months. I'm not sure the budget is there to bring Santi back without using a DP, and I don't think we want to burn it for him rather than a striker. It would be great if I'm wrong, of course.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Kjbert
This may be our squad for the next few months. I'm not sure the budget is there to bring Santi back without using a DP, and I don't think we want to burn it for him rather than a striker. It would be great if I'm wrong, of course.

The rumor is that Santi won't be a DP, but obviously that could be wrong.

I do think we have the salary cap space for him as a TAM player; we really should have plenty of space after all the departures.
 
I'll be interested to see how we lineup with Sands on the pitch - there's a lot of coverage needed for Chanot -- do we go to a 3ATB until LCB is straightened away or are we using Sands in the MF?

Or now that he's busted his goal scoring cherry do we think he's our next #9?




(joking about the 9...)

This was my hot take. I think he plays more as a CB in a 4-3-3 than as a CB in a 3 ATB or as a midfielder. I think he replaces Chanot.
 
The rumor is that Santi won't be a DP, but obviously that could be wrong.

I do think we have the salary cap space for him as a TAM player; we really should have plenty of space after all the departures.
We'll see. Something tells me Santi is looking for some money. If we can get there on TAM, great. But his ask might be somewhere beyond our constraints, and he may be able to get it (or at least a lot closer to it) elsewhere.

As it is, I'm just ecstatic to have James back. He's the guy I really wanted. With him back in the squad I think we can connect back to front and work it out alright with what we have.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Kjbert
NYCFC 2023 DEPTH CHART

Striker: Segal
Wing/Striker: Talles Magno, Thiago
Wing: Pereira, Jasson, Jimenez
Wing/CAM: Pellegrini
CAM: Carrizo
CM: Parks, Haak
CDM/CB: Sands, Morales
RB: Gray, Ilenič
LB: Cufre, O'Toole, Amundsen, McFarlane, Turnbull
CB: Chanot, Martins, Alfaro, Owusu, Benalcazar
GK: Barraza, Freese, Mizell
Small nitpick, but I think I would list Gray as RB/CB
 
i loved when we needed played Sands in the pivot from CDM to RB. line up with:
Thiago (striker DP)
Magno-Santi- periera
Morales - Parks
(Cufre/otoole)-Martins-Chanot- Sands

When we go to offense, sands pushes up to the CDM

Magno - Thaigo
Cufre-morales-Santi- parks-periera
Sands
Martins-Chanot
 
It's hard to say because I don't think they were doing this from year 1 so the sample size is small assuming they only started recently. Looking at the end of seasons releases table you posted previously 2021 possibly supports this idea.

In 2021 Mitrita was released at the end of the year and not replaced with Magno til July. Our two other largest salary expenses for 2021 were also delayed til July (Santi signing and Taty extension).

2022 is less supportive as Medina left at the end of the year and Martins arrived in time for the season so the DPs are a wash. I still think the Martins signing was less about team need and driven mostly by some type of CFG need to either shift his costs away from Yokohama or fix a situation where Martins was unhappy in Japan. From a non-DP standpoint, we shed large contracts of Thorarinsson and ITS and only took on Pellegrini who I assume was cheap as he was a buyout.

Very inconclusive but I don't think the recent data rules the theory out I think it's more of a too-early-to-tell situation.

screen-shot-2022-12-28-at-8-08-03-am-png.12458
I get the too-early-to-tell idea. But I also think 2021 is a poor data point. Remember that the 2020-2021 offseason was still pre-vaccine. What the season would look like was very uncertain. Teams were losing massive amounts of money with no idea what ticket sales would look like in 2021. Very hard for me to see that as early indication of a generalized strategy rather than randomness of the transfer market and/or anomaly of COVID.