Here's some statistical analysis I pulled/compiled from whoscored:
Dax and Felipe really ran the show for NJRB in their double pivot roles and we had no answer for them.
Dax: 82 touches (game high; #1 for us was Facey with 63!); 83% passing (66 passes; 2nd most in the game); dispossessed 0 times; 4 tackles and 8 interceptions; committed 0 fouls
Felipe: 77 touches (2nd highest in the game); 88% passing (67 passes - game high; #1 for us was Facey/Pirlo with 45 each); dispossessed just 1 time; 4 shots, 1 goal, 1 key pass
Miazga also had a great game and this kid has really taken the league by storm -- very bright future. He had 5 tackles, 2 interceptions, 8 clearances and 2 blocked shots. Lade added 8 interceptions of his own.
As a team, NJRB had 28 crosses with 10 accurate; 54 long balls (Robles had 14 of those) with 22 accurate; 5 through balls with 3 accurate. On the other hand, NYCFC had 24 crosses with 7 accurate; 57 long balls (Saunders had 17 of those) with 30! of those accurate, and exactly 0 through balls attempted.
Some other items that stood out to me:
Villa was dispossessed 5 times.
Lampard was dispossessed 4 times.
Pirlo was fouled 4 times.
NYCFC created a high number of key passes (14) many of which should have been finished and converted to assists: 4 key passes for Villa, 3 for McNamara, 3 for Pirlo, 2 for Lampard, 1 for Mix and 1 for Angelino.
Biggest issue for me is that no one in midfield (besides Mix) plays any defense. We don't get much from Pirlo or Lampard defensively (and that's not too surprising) but Jacobson was absolutely worthless. 100% of the defensive pressure is put on the back 4 and they did what they could:
Player - Tackles/Interceptions/Clearances
Facey - 4/4/9
Angelino - 3/3/6
Iraola - 5/1/4
Mena - 3/2/1
Jacobson - 0/1/0
Mix - 2/2/0
Lampard - 1/2/1
Pirlo - 0/2/0
Very bad news that our 2 Man City loanees are the best defensive players we have.